News
Amid Boston Overdose Crisis, a Pair of Harvard Students Are Bringing Narcan to the Red Line
News
At First Cambridge City Council Election Forum, Candidates Clash Over Building Emissions
News
Harvard’s Updated Sustainability Plan Garners Optimistic Responses from Student Climate Activists
News
‘Sunroof’ Singer Nicky Youre Lights Up Harvard Yard at Crimson Jam
News
‘The Architect of the Whole Plan’: Harvard Law Graduate Ken Chesebro’s Path to Jan. 6
Question: "Resolved, That the United States ought to construct a large system of irrigation works."
Brief for the Affirmative.
F. S. ELLIOTT and S. W. PHILLIPS.Best general references: Statement of Maj. Powell, House Ex. Doc. 51st Cong. 2nd Sess. (1890-91) No. 15; H. M. Wilson, Irrigation in India, House Ex. Doc. 52nd Cong. 1st Sess. (1891-92) No. 18; J. W. Irwin, A great Domain by Irrigation in Forum XII, 740 (Sept. 1891); Reports of Secs. of the Interior, House Ex. Docs. 51st Cong. 1st Sess. (1889-90) No. 13, and 51st Cong. 2nd Sess. (1890-91) No. 13.
I. Irrigation is of greatest value to the country. - (a) Large areas now worthless without it: Powell, 48. - (b) 120,000,000 acres reclaimable: Sec. Noble's Report 1891. - (c) Government no longer has any good agricultural land left. - (d) Irrigated land better for agriculture than common land. - (e) Irrigation has developed the country immensely. - (x) in India: Wilson 418-20. - (y) in Southern California and in New Mexico: Sec. Noble's Report, 1890, 608-9.
II. Irrigation is perfectly possible. - (a) There is plenty of water if it can be properly managed: Forum, XII, 745. - (b) Nature of soil is favorable; Forum, XII, 745-6. - (c) Conditions of India, where it has succeeded are similar: Wilson, 391.
III. Control of irrigation by others than the United States unwise. - (a) By states. - (1) River systems extend over several states. - (2) The one nearest the head could steal all the water: Powell, 221. - (b) By individual farmers. - It would be on too small a scale to be effective except in a few places: Powell, 237. - (c) By corporations. - (1) It leaves a great class of farmers at the mercy of the water companies. - (2) It would lead to the creation of large estates and the crushing out of small holders. - (3) It would lead to popular hatred, as in the case of railroads in the west.
IV. Irrigation to be successful must be by the United States: Sec. Noble's Report, 1890, 641. - (a) It must be on a very large scale: Powell, 48. - (b) Return from the investment, although sure, is very slow at first: Wilson, 410-18. - (c) It has to wait for immigration to fill up the irrigated land: Wilson, 381.
Brief for the Negative.
J. W. COOKE and V. H. MAY.Best general references: Forum, XII, 740, 1890; Whitney's "United States," supplement I; House Exec. Doc. 52 Cong. 1 Sess. (1891-92) p. 48; Senate Exec. Doc. 52 Cong. 1 Sess. (1891-92) IV.
I. The proposed system is inexpedient. - (a) Very expensive. - (b) Unwisely increases the civil service. - (c) Would divert public attention from more pressing questions. - (1) Finance. - (2) Tariff. - (3) Labor. - (d) Irrigation might be introduced for political motives. - (e) Gov't construction is usually lavish: Forum, XII, 740. - (f) Gov't control not economical: ibid. - (g) Example of India not applicable: Whitney's "United States," 34.
II. The constitutionality of such a system is questionable. - (a) Power not specifically granted in constitution. - (b) Such power not easily inferred.
III. Whatever is necessary can be done without government intervention. - (a) Private enterprise most economical: Forum, XII, 740. - (b) Private capital is able to create and manage such a system. - (1) Private capitalists have undertaken such works in the west, as in New Mexico: House Exec. Doc. 51 Cong. 2 Sess. (1890-91) VIII, 608. - (2) Private capitalists have undertaken equally large operations. - (x) Niagara Falls Water Power Co. - (y) Great railway systems.
IV. Possible abuses can be prevented by state and government oversight: Forum, XII, 740.
V. There are many obstacles to irrigation on a large scale. - (a) Insufficiency of water supply. - (b) Danger from large reservoirs. - (c) Destructive alkaline deposits.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.