News
Amid Boston Overdose Crisis, a Pair of Harvard Students Are Bringing Narcan to the Red Line
News
At First Cambridge City Council Election Forum, Candidates Clash Over Building Emissions
News
Harvard’s Updated Sustainability Plan Garners Optimistic Responses from Student Climate Activists
News
‘Sunroof’ Singer Nicky Youre Lights Up Harvard Yard at Crimson Jam
News
‘The Architect of the Whole Plan’: Harvard Law Graduate Ken Chesebro’s Path to Jan. 6
Question: "Resolved. That it will be the duty of the next Congress to build additional new ships for the navy."
Brief for the Affirmative.
F. VON BRIESEN and R. WALCOTT.Best general references: Cong. Record, vol. 24 (Feb. 20, 1893); (Pendleton) vol. 27, p. 2543 (1895); (Adams) vol. 27, p. 2575; (Lodge) vol. 27, p. 2709; (Higgins) vol. 27, p.2573, (Chandler); vol. 27, p. 3583; Forum, 1890, p. 323; N. A. Rev., vol. 149, pp. 54-65, and July 1893; Overland Monthly, xiii (April 1889), xxiv (Oct. 1894) (Lieut. E. Gualtrough); Statesman's Year Book 1894, pp. 1080-1084; Report of Naval Committee of House, Cong. Rec. vol. 27, p. 2484; Naval Register for 1894; Report of Sec. Herbert in Abridged Documents (H. C. 2000) 424-429; Mahan's Sea Power, 1-89.
I. It is desirable for the maintenance of national respect: Mahan's Sea Power; Pres. Cleveland's message, Dec. 1885. - (a) To protect Americans abroad. - (1) Madagascar. - (2) Blue fields. - (3) Colombia. - (b) To add weight to demands. - (c) To prevent insults. - (1) Case of Allianca.
II. It is necessary for purposes of defense. - (a) Extensive seaboard 16,000 miles and Alaska. - (b) Increasing commerce: U. S. Report on Commerce, 1894. - (c) Inadequate coast defenses: Gualtrough. - (d) International complications can not be avoided. - (1) Chile. - (2) Samoa. - (3) Hawaii. - (4) Nicaragua. - (5) Great Britain as to Behring Sea. - (6) Spain as to Cuba. - (e) Monroe Doctrine should be enforced.
III. It is necessary for purposes of offense. - (a) Prevention of European interference with America. - (b) Necessary in case of war: Comparison of Navies in Herbert's Report.
IV. Coast defenses alone are inadequate: Bartlett in Cong. Rec. vol. 27, p. 2547.
V. Cessation of building would be an abrupt break in the policy adhered to since 1886: Herbert, p. 424. - (a) Additional ships should be ordered by next Congress for - (1) Usual time for building a battle-ship is 5 years. - (2) Cramp can not construct the best in less than 2 1/2 years: Higgins in Cong. Rec. Vol. 27, p. 3576. - (b) Provision for - (1) Sudden shipwreck, cf. Reina Regente. - (2) Ordinary wear and tear. - (3) Filling place of older ships made nearly useless by modern improvements.
Brief for the Negative.
M. A. ALDRICH and J. W. WORTHINGTON.Best general references: Nation, vol. 54, p. 41; vol. 59, p. 230; vol 60, p. 138; A. B. Hart, The Chilean Controversy, in Practical Essays; Cong. Rec. 1894-5, pp. 2504, 2546, 3577; Senate Rep. No. 174, 51st Cong., 1st Session; House Exec. Doc. 49th Cong. 1st Session, No. 28.
I. The policy of the U. S. is opposed to a large navy. - (a) Not pugnacious. - (b) No entangling alliances: Century, vol. 37, p. 951 (Apr. '89).
II. An increase is unnecessary. - (a) Navy is already considerable: Rep. Sec. of Navy for 1894, p. 6. - (b) More ships are authorized: Boston Herald, Mar. 5, 1895. - (c) No analogy with European navies - (1) Small commerce. - (2) No colonies. - (3) Isolation. - (d) War is not probable. - (1) No strong neighbors. - (2) European nations desire peace with U. S. - (w) Respect our neutrality. - (x) War with U. S. would precipitate general European war. - (y) Great foreign investments in U. S. - (z) Arbitration probable.
III. An increase is undesirable. - (a) We already have a deficit. - (b) Navy expensive: Cong. Rec. 1894-5, p. 2492. - (c) Promotes jingoism. - (1) Barrundia and Chile: A. B. Hart, above.
IV. Money may be better spent. - (a) Encouragement of commerce. - (b) Better diplomatic service. - (c) Reserves of ordnance: Rep. Sec. Navy, 1894, p. 16. - (d) Adequate coast defence: Cong. Rec. 1894-5, p. 2546.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.