In his reply to the Advocate's charge of a paternalistic censorship by the Widener authorities, it is startling to find Mr. Lane, the librarian, calmly admitting the present censorship and arguing the right, even duty, of his assistants to decide what is and what is not fit pabulum for student minds. "There are", says Mr. Lane, "filthy books, salacious books, books corrupting in influence, which it is no part of the Library's duty to distribute to readers." Thus he lays claim to the right of censorship, to the right to deck Boccaccio and Ellis with fig leaves.
This attitude might be permissible were he referring to public libraries in general. But Widener library is not a public library. It is the private library of Harvard University used by a select group of fairly mature students possessed of good breeding and good sense. These men need no "great-grandmotherly" supervision of their morals and the attempt to infringe their independence of thought is an insult to their character.
But even granting the Widener authorities to be acting within their rights, the unfortunate effect of a successful censorship is to defeat its own purpose. Information withheld with the nursing of lips seems invariably to attain an unjustified rapacity of circulation. Filth which is innocuous on the printed page becomes effective through being spread by word of mouth. The excitement aroused by censorship creates a volume of curiosity far greater than the salacious matter would of itself admit. The very effectiveness of censorship destroys its intended effect.
The ultimate question is of granting the college student a maximum of intellectual freedom. The undergraduate is well-poised: he will not be unbalanced by reading about a few doubtful subjects always in common talk. And openness of approach to written knowledge of esoteric subjects will go far to dissipate the halo of naughtiness which clings about the prurient taboo.
Publisher Opposes Censorship MotionsFreedom of the press has been endangered by recent attempts to establish censorship of pocket books and magazines, Thomas J.
Harvard Forum.The regular meeting of the Forum was held last night in Harvard 1. The question: "That censorship of the press
BACKSLIDINGThe Gorgon of Faculty censorship has raised its snaky locks at Ann Arbor: as a result, sixteen members of the
"CENSORSHIP IS THE BUNK" SAYS CANTOR AT LUNCHEONAt a luncheon given in the Union yesterday' "Eddie" Canlor, now starring in "Kid Boots," was the guest of honor.
Harvard Bibliophiles Censure CensorshipWhen students in 1924 accused Widener Library administrators of censorship, one librarian at the time called the act a “duty.”