In March, Council members Aurelio Torre '00, Brian R. Smith '02 and Bradley L. Davis '00 sponsored a bill that endorsed the return of the Reserve Officers Training Corps (ROTC) to Harvard.
Currently, Harvard students who wish to participate in ROTC must travel to MIT to do so. The University banned ROTC from campus in 1969, when tensions over the Vietnam War enraged student activists. In 1994, the University stopped payments to MIT for the ROTC program, citing concerns about discrimination against gay students.
The original bill proposed by Torre, Davis and Smith specifically asked for a campus ROTC program. The amended bill they offered to the council instead called upon the University to allow recruiters on campus, provide shuttle service for cadets to MIT for training and reassume responsibility for funding Harvard cadets.
Davis said he thought the compromise bill would satisfy more people.
"There is a way to work with these students and respect what they do without breaking Harvard's non-discrimination policies," he said.
Many students still expressed dismay over what they saw as a tacit endorsement of the military's discriminatory "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
The authors steadfastly promoted the legislation as a practical service for students rather than a political statement.
"This isn't an issue of left, this isn't an issue of right.... This is an issue of student services," Torre said during the debate on the council floor.
"When I wrote the bill, my main idea was that we shouldn't reject the [organization] because of one particular aspect," he said in an interview.
But that one aspect was enough to spawn over 130 e-mail messages to uc-general, many of them vehement, arguing the bill.
Smith was the quietest of the three. An Air Force ROTC cadet, he stressed over and over that he didn't want his comments to be construed as representative of the military's stance and provided little more than explanations of Harvard's current policy.
When questioned during the debate, Smith talked about the inconveniences involved with things like recruiting.
"You either seek out someone, or ROTC cadets can talk to people on their own. We can't [recruit] openly," he explained.
The legislation was heavily amended and passed by the council, changed to condemn discrimination in the military and stopped short of endorsing a battalion on campus. But it remains to be seen if Torre, Davis and Smith's victory will produce anything more than overloaded e-mail accounts now that it has been passed on to the administration.
ROTC Bills Stalled in Senate CommitteeThreats to slash federal funding to colleges and universities that refuse to allow the Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC) on
Council Sparks Debate With Proposal to Reconsider ROTCUndergraduate Council members drafted a bill Tuesday that would express support for bringing the Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC) back
Keep ROTC Off CampusHarvard students in the military's Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC) program have not been able to take their classes on
Council Endorses Return of ROTCRecent Undergraduate Council meetings have barely attracted a quorum of members. It was difficult to find a seat, though, at
Council Considers Decreasing Size and Changing NameMaybe they were riding high on the success of Springfest. Whatever the reason, an unusually giddy Undergraduate Council considered re-inventing
Council Asks University To Help Cadets Earn ROTC CreditThe University should make it easier for students in the Reserve Officers Training Corps (ROTC) to count Harvard courses for