Westfall, who held the Gray and Schipper professorships, taught a mandatory first-year property-law course for all 50 years that he was an HLS faculty member. In recent years, however, he had branched out to labor law and family law.
By all accounts, Westfall enjoyed teaching and was loved by his students.
Some of these students, like Bromley Professor of Law Arthur R. Miller, whom Westfall taught in 1957, became Westfall’s friends and colleagues in later years.
“I was very close to him, as his student, which is unusual at HLS, because it’s so big,” said Miller. “He was user-friendly, in that he always had time
Stephen B. Burbank ’68, who is Watson visiting professor at HLS and also one of Westfall’s former students, described a similar accessibility in Westfall.
“He was not a hierarchical person at all—it was easy to become his friend and remain his friend for decades,” said Burbank, who graduated from HLS in 1973.
Burbank said Westfall was a unique professor during that era.
“David was somebody that we would call quite ‘laid-back’ and, at the time, there was a pretty striking contrast between him and a lot of the faculty, who were like characters out of ‘[The] Paper Chase,’” Burbank said. “He was the antithesis of that—a gentleman who elicited participation not by fear but by inviting a dialogue.”
“David cared a great deal about the quality of his teaching, he cared a great deal about the material that he loved...and he had a tremendous rapport with students,” Miller said. “In the long course of his professional life, he impacted many people who are now at the top of the legal profession...great practitioners, great judges, and a large number of academics.
“He taught subjects that are very important, that will never be taught as well again,” Miller added. Westfall also wrote a book on family law published in 1994. A casebook and supplement to his book on estate-planning law and taxation appeared in 2001.
Despite the fact that he was “a very much appreciated and highly-regarded colleague,” said his friend, Royall Professor of Law David R. Herwitz, “he never took himself too seriously.”
Beyond his work at HLS, Westfall was also passionate about travel.
“In the last few years of his life, teaching and traveling abroad became absolutely central to his life,” Miller said. “He would teach short courses in Germany, South America, Turkey...He was enjoying that part of his later years. It was a sad thing when his illness got to be so severe that he had to stop traveling.”
A few months ago, when Westfall announced that he could no longer teach, his students decided to continue studying the subject on their own, rather than to request another professor. They felt that anybody else would be too much of a departure from Westfall’s style, according to Herwitz.
And, said Miller, this affinity was mutual.
“He would say to me, long before he was ill, that he could not imagine life without teaching,” he said. “And, indeed, he wanted to die in the classroom.”