As a judge heard arguments for the first time relating to B. Denise Cosby’s wrongful death lawsuit against Harvard for the 2009 murder of her son in Kirkland House, lawyers for Harvard said that the University cannot be held responsible for the drug deal gone wrong, and the suit should be dismissed.
Harvard’s attorneys maintained that the University had no duty to protect 21-year-old Justin D. C. D. Cosby, who came to the Harvard dormitory for what he believed was a marijuana deal. Instead, he was held at gunpoint by three men demanding that he hand over the drugs. When he refused, one of the men shot him.
In oral argument in Middlesex Superior Court on Wednesday, Harvard’s lead attorney Martin F. Murphy stressed the point that has been the University’s main contention since the suit was filed in May. “Particularly [when] the plaintiff himself has come onto the property in order to engage in dangerous activities,” Murphy argued, “the law makes it clear that [Harvard] doesn’t have that duty of safety to [Cosby].”
Neither side has contested that Cosby came to Harvard that day to sell drugs. But Denise Cosby’s lawyers argued Wednesday, as they have since May, that the dangerous situation developed only because of Harvard’s lax enforcement of its own regulations. One of the three men involved in the hold-up, Jabrai Jordan Copney, had been living for months with his girlfriend, Harvard senior Brittany J. Smith, in her Lowell House single—a clear violation of rules printed in Harvard's student handbook and elsewhere.
As a result of Harvard’s inattention, Cosby’s lawyers say, Copney ran “a criminal enterprise” out of Smith’s Lowell dorm room. Before Cosby’s murder in May 2009, Copney and his friend Blayn Jiggetts, also later involved in Cosby’s killing, had used a firearm to steal drugs from two Yale dealers whom Cosby met during Harvard-Yale weekend.
“[Copney] was there for two semesters,” Cosby’s lead attorney Isaac H. Peres said, “not two days, not three days.... The only reason this became a situation is because of [Harvard’s] negligence.”
Copney was convicted of first-degree murder in Middlesex Superior Court last year and is serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole. His two associates, Jiggetts and Jason F. Aquino, each pleaded guilty to manslaughter, and Smith pleaded guilty to accessory charges.
Denise Cosby and Gregory Daniel Cosby, the uncle of the shooting victim, watched the proceedings.
“We’re cautiously optimistic. You never know about these things, but we felt that it went well and that [the judge] understood our argument,” Peres said afterward. The judge will hand down an opinion on whether the case should be dismissed at an unannounced time.
—Staff writer Matthew Q. Clarida can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Two Defendants To Face Trial in April; Two Likely To Plead GuiltyAs legal proceedings move forward against the four defendants charged with participating in the 2009 killing in the basement of Kirkland House, two defendants plan to plead guilty while the two others—the man who allegedly pulled the trigger and the Harvard student who is charged with aiding the murderers—are set to stand trial next month.
Kirkland Shooting Victim's Mother Sues HarvardThe mother of a 21-year-old man who was fatally shot in a Harvard dormitory three years ago claims that Harvard’s negligence in allowing a drug dealer to live in Lowell for months led to the wrongful death of her son.
Harvard Seeks To Dismiss Cosby Civil SuitFacing a lawsuit faulting the University and Lowell House administrators for the death of a 21-year-old man on Harvard’s campus in 2009, Harvard said in a legal filing last week that it cannot be blamed for the death of a non-student drug dealer who was killed during a transaction in Kirkland House.
Cosby Wrongful Death Suit Against Harvard DismissedA Massachusetts court has dismissed the wrongful death suit filed against Harvard and three of its employees by the mother of Justin D. C. D. Cosby.
Killing Suspects To Plead GuiltyBlayn Jiggetts and Jason Aquino—two of the three men implicated in the May 2009 Kirkland House shooting—have made an agreement with prosecutors to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for cooperating with the district attorney’s office.