Dec. 18, 2009
Public opinion plays like a broken record. As the New Jersey bill to legalize same-sex marriage floats and flounders in the state legislature, I can’t help feeling that I’ve heard the same sound-bite arguments from supporters and detractors a million times. Groups with names like Garden State Equality and Progressive Change Committee Campaign decry empty promises of the pursuit of happiness and the withholding of individual rights. They yell and scream across the aisle at the Council on the American Family and the Coalition to Preserve and Protect Marriage, products of the 90s culture wars, which judging by the media clips, continue unabated.
Somewhere in all this mess, it’s become painfully apparent that the camps are talking past each other. In my perspective, advocates for same-sex marriage could go about advancing the message with a bit more tact. Although the proponents of marriage equality have made tremendous strides—achievements should be rightfully recognized and applauded—we must now engage socially-conservative opponents on their own turf. In addition to emphasizing the case for same-sex marriage in terms of individual freedom and rights, we must add community-oriented dimensions to the message. Progressives need to stress that same-sex marriage won’t erode institutions conservatives hold dear—in fact, it might very well strengthen them.
(Continued)