News
Amid Boston Overdose Crisis, a Pair of Harvard Students Are Bringing Narcan to the Red Line
News
At First Cambridge City Council Election Forum, Candidates Clash Over Building Emissions
News
Harvard’s Updated Sustainability Plan Garners Optimistic Responses from Student Climate Activists
News
‘Sunroof’ Singer Nicky Youre Lights Up Harvard Yard at Crimson Jam
News
‘The Architect of the Whole Plan’: Harvard Law Graduate Ken Chesebro’s Path to Jan. 6
DEBATE OF MAY 22, 1889.Question: "Resolved, That the United States should restore its shipping by subsidies."
Brief for the Affirmative.C. D. Wetmore and G. E. Wright.
Best general references: C. S. Hill's "Our Merchant Marine;" speech of John Roach, Boston, October 7, 1880. [Both in U. 14].
I. A national merchant marine is of the greatest importance to the commercial prosperity of the country-C. S. Hill's History of American Shipping, P. 132; Report of the Secretary of Treasury, 1872, p. 10.
II. A large merchant marine is essential to naval power-Kelley's Question of Ships, p 108; Brassey's British Navy, vol. 2. pp 317-320; Lalor's Cyclopaedia, vol. 2, p 987.
III. Our country should regain its former maritime prestige because of (a) our national instinct-speech of Eustis, Congressional Record, vol. 17, p 4083; (b) our geographical position-Overland Monthly, 1883, p 462.
IV. Subsidies will restore the hammer to the shioyard, develop commerce, and prove a boon to American labor-Report of select committee, 1882, p 109; H. A. Hill's American Shipping, p 29.
V. Subsidies will restore our merchan their shipping by subsidies-"Our Merchant Marin," pp 10-19, and 28; Report of select committee, 1870, p 7; House Ex. Doc., 45th congress, second session, vol. 8, p 9; (b) we have tried such a policy and have found it effective-Lindsey's Merchant Shipping, vol. 4, pp 194-228; speech of Hale in Cong. Record, vol. 17, p 4009.
VI. Without subsidies our steamship line cannot compete with the highly subsidized foreign lines-Thompson's "Protection," p 99; House Reports, 46th congress, second session volume 5, no. 1570.
Brief for the Negative.C. D. Gibbons and J. P. Nields.
Best general references:- Well's, Our Merchant Marine; Codman on Shipbuilders and Commerce.
I. American shipping interest can be restored without the cost of subsidies by a revision of the navigation law; primarily, by a revision in favor of the free purchase and ownership of vessels for foreign trade.- Well's Our Merchant Marine pp. 95-128; North American Review, vol. 142, pp. 481-484; Codman in Shipbuilders and Commerce phamphlets 4 and 2; Atlantic, vol. 53, p. 800.
II. Subsidies are objectionable, (a) artificial and temporizing expedients-Well's Our Merchant Marine, pp. 136-139. (b) have proved failures.- Well's, 138-140, 162-165, 113 115; (c) would be a tremendous cost.- Well's, p. 140; Codman, pp. 14, 18, 25; Congressional Globe, 1869-70, part 5, p. 3786; (d) profit would come wholly from subsidies.- Well's, pp. 140-142 (e) have proved and always will prove inducements to corrupt legislature.- Well's p. 139, Cong. Globe, 1869-70, part 5, p. 3860; (f) benefit one party at the expense of the whole country.- Well's, p. 141; Codman p. 15; Cong. Globe, 1869-70, part 5, p 3860; (g) would make shippers uneconomical and would destroy all competition.
III. It is not expedient to encourage capital to enter an occupation which we must pursue at a relative disadvantage.- Lindsay Merchant Shipping, III 83-187, IV. 163 180, 292, 316, 376; N. A. Rev., Oct. 1864.
IV. We have lost our former prestige on the ocean by natural causes; that position cannot be restored by the artificial means of subsidies.- Roach's View in Lynch's Rep.; Kelly, Question of Ships; Every Saturday, vol. X p. 170.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.