News
Amid Boston Overdose Crisis, a Pair of Harvard Students Are Bringing Narcan to the Red Line
News
At First Cambridge City Council Election Forum, Candidates Clash Over Building Emissions
News
Harvard’s Updated Sustainability Plan Garners Optimistic Responses from Student Climate Activists
News
‘Sunroof’ Singer Nicky Youre Lights Up Harvard Yard at Crimson Jam
News
‘The Architect of the Whole Plan’: Harvard Law Graduate Ken Chesebro’s Path to Jan. 6
Question: Resolved, That the Silver Act of 1890 was an unwise measure.
Brief for the Affirmative.
A. F. COSBY and J. D. UPTON.
Best general references: F. W. Taussig. Silver Situation in the U. S.; J. L. Laughlin, Bimetallism Chs. XIII, XIV; Nineteenth Century, XXVIII. 309-324. (Aug. 1890); Nation LII. 24 (Jan. 8, 1891). LIII. (Jul. 23, 1891); Jevons, Investigation in Currency and Finance, 303-316.
I. A double standard is necessary. - (a) Experience of the U. S. up to 1878. - (b) Example of England and Germany. - (c) Single gold standard is the best. - (d) Credit is dependent on gold as it is the basis of loans - (e) Bank notes can supply any needful currency: Jevons, Invest., 305.
II. The bill when passed was unsatisfactory. - (a) No improvement on the Brand Act. - (b) Measure was simply a compromise and satisfied nobody. - (c) Currency should not be changed so often. - (d) Arguments for the bill unsound. - (1) To raise the price of silver. - (2) To inflate the currency. - (e) Unnecessary locking up of bullion: Nineteenth Cent. Aug. '90, p. 309.
III. It is has not fulfilled it object. - (a) Silver did not rise permanently: Silver Situation, 52 - (b) Prices have not risen - (c) Has not caused a revival of general activity. - (d) Silver Agitation was not stopped: Nation LII, (Jan. 8, '91.) - (e) Gen. Sherman grants that the bill was a failure: Ibid.
IV. It is a most dangerous measure. - (a) It tends to drive us toward a silver standard. - (b) We cannot absorb the new silver. - (c) Our gold reserve has been weakened: Nation LII, (July 23, 1891. - (d) Banks are compelled to help the Treasury - (e) It diminishes the surplus and weakens the Treasury. - (f) In 1891 we barely escaped financial trouble. - (g) A panic may come at any time.
Brief for the Negative.
J. ALLEN and F. W. MOORE.
Best general references: Cong. Rec. 1889-90, XXI, June and July: F. W. Taussig in Forum X, 165, (Oct. 1890): Public Opinion, June 14, 19, 1890: Report of Sec. of the Treas. 1890 p.p. 20-33: G. S. Boutwell, Silver as a Circulating Medium, in Forum XI, 10 March, 1891.
I. Some financial legislation was demanded. - (a) Because of growth of business: Taussig in Forum, as above. - (b) Ultimate retirement of bank notes: Cong. Rec. XXI, 5652. - (c) Act. of 1878 insufficient and unpopular: Rep. of Sec. of Treas. 1890, p, 33.
II. Use of silver for currency necessary. - (a) Gold supply inadequate: Voorhees in N. Am. Rev. vol. 153 p. 524, Nov. 1891.
III. This act was a necessary compromise. - (a) House bill insisted on bullion redemption. Senate bill proposed free coinage: Nation June 19, 1890. - (c) This act reported by conference committee, supported by Sherman, Walker and other sound money men.
IV. The Act has been beneficial. - (a) It gave the needed increase of currency. (b) It provided a convenient substitute for coin. - (c) It did away with the needless coinage of silver. - (d) It postponed the free coinage crisis until public opinion had been aroused.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.