Med School Hosts Asian American Conference

"Breaking the Silence" Features Discussions of 'Model Minority' Myth, Cultural Pressures

BOSTON--More than half of Asians living in Chinatown are uninsured, and the utilization of health care services by Asian elderly people is one-third less than average, panelists told 120 gathered at the Medical School this weekend for what organizers called the first conference to be held on Asian American health issues.

A former gang member and a national expert on AIDS were just two of the panelists who spoke Saturday at "Breaking the Silence," co-sponsored by the Asian Health Association and Ayurveda, the South Asian medical student organization, of the Medical School.

The day-long conference consisted of three panel discussions on issues affecting the Asian American community: AIDS and substance abuse, health care delivery, and violence.

Medical problems specific to the Asian population brought up during the conference included a high incidence of stomach cancer, tuberculosis and hepatitis. But most of the Asian health problems, said the panelists, stemmed from the stereotype of Asians as a "model minority" and the strong cultural pressure for Asians not to reveal their problems.

For example, said panelist Suki T. Ports, who heads various minority AIDS councils, Asians won't go to psychological support groups because it's shameful to do so in the Chinese community. And since being gay is frowned upon in the Asian community, no Asian homosexual support groups exist.


The strong aversion of Asians toward talking about sex also contributes to the spread of AIDS, said Ports, who threw out wrapped condoms into the audience at the beginning of the conference.

Dr. Jean Chin, a panelist and executive director of an Asian community health center in Boston, called for more Asian primary care physicians who could be "culturally competent" in servicing the needs of an Asian patient.

"We have found that being Asian is important [for primary care physicians]," said Chin. "There are certain elements in the context of the visit that makes for more competent care."

Hiep Chu, a panelist and former Vietnamese refugee, said in Vietnam, health care is virtually non-existent, so Vietnamese-Americans do not use health care services until it's too late.

"They won't visit hospitals and doctors even if they're very sick," he said.

Stereotypes and a closed culture both help spread the mistaken belief that Asians don't have health problems, and therefore don't need health care funding or special assistance, the panelists said. "We've had to threaten state departments with lawsuits to get funding," said Ports.

Other panelists said domestic violence, anti-Asian violence, and substance abuse were also not recognized in the Asian community because of the "model minority" myth.

For example, a Japanese exchange student killed in California was left dead with his wallet and belongings, yet the police still insisted it was an attempted robbery rather than a hate crime, said Helen Zia, former executive editor of Ms. magazine and currently director of an Asian women's shelter.

Atul Gawande, a third-year Medical School student and former advisor to the Clinton task force on health care, urged Asian-Americans to concentrate on universality and cost-containment rather than specific issues.

"Overall, improvements in longevity and health status for Asians have lagged compared to the average Americans," Gawande said.

Recommended Articles