News

Progressive Labor Party Organizes Solidarity March With Harvard Yard Encampment

News

Encampment Protesters Briefly Raise 3 Palestinian Flags Over Harvard Yard

News

Mayor Wu Cancels Harvard Event After Affinity Groups Withdraw Over Emerson Encampment Police Response

News

Harvard Yard To Remain Indefinitely Closed Amid Encampment

News

HUPD Chief Says Harvard Yard Encampment is Peaceful, Defends Students’ Right to Protest

Evidence For Cartoonist’s Firing Is Flimsy At Best

By Roxanne Palmer

To the editors:

The Crimson’s decision to fire Kathleen Breeden is hasty and ill-justified.

Of the two cartoons that were cited in your Oct. 30 editors’ note as exhibiting overt plagiarism, Breeden’s Oct. 25 cartoon is a particularly weak example. Professional cartoonist Daryl Cagle points out on his website that a “t-shirt or sign pointing at something with a comment ‘I’m with stupid’ is a recurring…theme” among cartoonists.

I’m also curious as to why the editorial staff felt it was necessary to mention Breeden’s Oct. 11 cartoon (with Kim Jong Il’s hair depicted as a mushroom cloud) when the editors’ note itself states that this image was employed by at least four different artists. Breeden’s only crime is that in a select few of her pieces she went for an obvious gag, an offense quite common in editorial cartooning, worthy of a reprimand, at most, but certainly not a pink slip.

It’s understandable that, given recent events, The Crimson’s editorial board is jumping at the chance to come down hard on a case of alleged plagiarism. It’s a shame, though, that the newspaper would jettison a talented artist on such flimsy evidence.

ROXANNE PALMER

Providence, R.I.

October 31, 2006

The writer is an editorial cartoonist for the Brown Daily Herald.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.

Tags