The Institute of Politics may have stripped Chelsea Manning of her visiting fellowship last month, but that did not stop her from coming to Cambridge and meeting with Harvard students.
In a small, unpublicized event held at the Democracy Center on Oct. 3, Manning met with around 30 students from organizations including the Kennedy School’s Progressive Organizing Committee and the Harvard Trans Task Force.
“Her perspective is badly needed both at Harvard and across the country, and Harvard is worse off without her as a fellow,” Noah R. Wagner ’18, who attended the event, said.
The group sat around in a circle, with some students on the floor, according to Trans Task Force member Lily M. Velona ’18, who described the event as “a conversation” with Manning.
Velona said the group discussed topics including U.S. military tactics, Manning’s experience in prison, and the reason they were not meeting officially on campus: Harvard’s about-face rescinding of Manning's Visiting Fellow title last month.
Manning, a former U.S. army soldier and transgender rights activist, drew nationwide controversy after leaking several hundred thousand classified military documents. She was convicted and sentenced to 35 years in prison in 2013, though then-President Barack Obama commuted her sentence in January.
The day after the Kennedy School announced Manning’s appointment, Kennedy School senior fellow and former CIA deputy director Michael J. Morell resigned and CIA Director Mike Pompeo did not show up to a speaking engagement at the IOP, both in protest of Manning's hiring. Hours later, the IOP withdrew Manning’s offer, drawing nationwide ire.
Doug Gavel, a spokesperson for Harvard Kennedy School, confirmed in an email that “the IOP was not involved” in organizing Manning's appearance at the Democracy Center.
Velona said that the change in plans made for a better, more intimate conversation last week.
"It was everything that bringing her to the IOP probably wouldn't have been," Velona said. “Just sitting on the floor and talking and thinking things out.”
In his letter announcing Manning’s fellowship had been rescinded, Dean of Harvard Kennedy School Doug W. Elmendorf said Manning was still invited to spend the day on campus, just not with the fellow title. The New York Times later reported that Manning declined the modified invitation.
Students who were originally excited to see Manning named a Visiting Fellow were glad to still be able to meet her. Wagner, also a member of the Trans Task Force, said the discussion “left me feeling invigorated.”
“Chelsea Manning is a personal hero of mine for the same reasons that she is an unparalleled figure in American politics," Wagner said. "No whistleblower has ever received a sentence as long and harsh as the sentence Chelsea faced, and after such harsh repression, few people would continue speaking out as boldly as Chelsea has since her release."—Staff writer Graham W. Bishai can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow him on Twitter @GrahamBishai.
After Backlash, Kennedy School Withdraws Manning's Fellowship
Letter to the Editor: Set the Record Straight on Chelsea ManningWe call upon the Harvard Kennedy School to reinstate Chelsea Manning’s designation as a fellow at the Institute of Politics.
When Ideology Eclipses TruthInstead of standing up for their decision and following through with the principles they acted upon by appointing Manning, the Kennedy School has caved to ideological pressure.
Pleasing the CrowdThe Kennedy School has helped demonstrate that public opinion and optics outweigh a commitment to open intellectual inquiry and diverse, critical academic discourse.
Kennedy School Reassessing 'Fellow' Title Following Manning Controversy