Diehards Anonymous
As toxic as it may be, the sheer level of loyalty I’ve poured into the Los Angeles Angels cedes yet another point to the sunk-cost fallacy.
My hometown team, the Toronto Blue Jays, had long been mumbling in mediocrity. As a supercilious contrarian desperate for attention, I quickly settled on my new favorite team: the ascendant Los Angeles Angels, the appeal of which derived not so much from their merit as a team than the fact that none of my friends had heard of them.
It was a perfectly thought-out scheme by seven-year-old Cyrus: memorize everything about the Angels (without knowing a damn thing about the rules of baseball) so that when my classmates regurgitated their fathers’ sports takes during recess, I could outclass them by casually dropping that left-fielder J.B. Shuck was hitting .167. Oh, you say, you haven’t heard of the fifth-place runner-up for Rookie of the Year in 2013? I wonder who’s the real baseball fan now. Patronizing innocent children was certainly a surefire way to make friends.
I played my first year of organized baseball at the age of eight, much later than most children who are serious about the game. As the infield rover (a position the coaches made up) for a youth league team called the Sky Sox, I inhabited the best of both worlds. With a green mesh jersey in my closet, I could truthfully tell my friends I played baseball. And during practice, instead of fielding ground balls, an unathletic brigade of geeky faculty brats joined me in a donnish dugout delirium as we perched atop the backstop fence and invented nicknames for our star players.
Once, during batting practice, a burly teammate told me as I was sashaying my 25-inch yellow Easton aluminum bat, “Cyrus, plant your feet on the ground. Don’t be a baseball ballerina.” He was onto me. I notched a hit in both of my at-bats that day. I’ve yet to stop overcompensating.
Later that year, the Blue Jays made the playoffs for the first time in 22 years. Pandemonium. Fueled by franchise face José Bautista and MVP Josh Donaldson, they made a legendary run to the American League Championship Series before falling in six to the eventual champion Kansas City Royals. It was insane — everyone I knew was suddenly hooked on baseball. And I could finally show off my elite ball knowledge to guys who weren’t just humoring me anymore.
On my dad’s advice, I started to collect baseball cards, and for my ninth birthday, I invited a mix of my bro-iest friends to a Jays game, even though it was way up in the nosebleed seats of the cavernous Rogers Centre. For a little while, up until hockey season rolled around again and my athletically inclined classmates left me in the dust, I was kinda cool.
But something remained off. Beneath a buckling fear that my peers might prudently perceive my fandom as subterfuge, I had now assimilated the Angels into my personality. Following a conference in Southern California, my dad obtained for me a carmine shirsey of #27 Mike Trout, which I sported constantly until it was two sizes too small. What had once been a charade was now the ward of my very own conservatorship.
Another issue was that the very same year I went all-in, they started to suck. Really bad.
As my school hitched a lift on the Blue Jays bandwagon and escorted Canada’s team the farthest they’d made it in a generation, I witnessed the Texas Rangers drain my newfound lifeblood on the last day of the regular season. Eleven years later, the Angels have yet to play another game in October.
But I’m still watching. I’ve spent the majority of my life lambasting the Angels’ now-former owner, Arte Moreno, who miraculously mismanaged the team out of a playoff spot year after year, even after signing Japanese superstar #17 Shohei Ohtani before the 2018 season. And then he hit the skids.
In 2023, after Shohei departed the team in free agency, the then-two-time MVP had yet to get a taste of postseason action. “Are the Angels wasting his career??” screamed every clickbait YouTube thumbnail. To buttress his one-of-a-kind prowess, the rest of the team played like a festering heap of trash as Moreno professed that “the number one thing fans want is affordability” – not winning, and certainly not joy. Silly me.
And as masochistic as my fandom normally is, every now and then the Angels give me that sweet shot of hopium to jolt my expectations out of a cynical cesspool.
On May 10, 2022, southpaw Reid Detmers threw a no-hitter in just his eleventh career game as extortionate third baseman Anthony Rendon hit a left-handed home run to give the team an insurmountable lead. During a doubleheader on July 27, 2023, Shohei threw a dominant shutout in the first game before crushing two home runs in the nightcap en route to the Angels’ most aggressive (and ill-fated) trade deadline in years. And back in April, I opened my phone on Monday morning to see that right fielder Jo Adell had robbed three home runs in the same game, a first in baseball history.
Maybe it’s these moments that keep me going as Canada’s biggest (only) Angels fan. The facetious saying goes that 90 percent of gamblers quit just seconds before they win big. I’ve been betting my happiness on this pathetic bunch of losers for most of my conscious life, and they keep fooling me with the same old bait-and-switch. They continue to drift around aimlessly – unwilling to commit to winning, but worst of all, unwilling to commit to losing. As other teams trade away their stars and stockpile draft picks for a future playoff run, the Angels have four long seasons remaining on Trout’s exorbitant contract.
A lack of ambition is crippling, but a lack of direction is calamitous. This stupid obsession is a means for me to exert control over something in life, even if “control” is just another word for screaming at the TV while a feeble offence manages just two hits against an also-ran Minnesota Twins team.
Realistically, the only thing that predictably affects a team’s success is injury. Maybe Detmers stretched particularly well before his no-hitter, or maybe Adell watched a hilarious Instagram reel before his one-of-a-kind defensive performance. I know blowing a gasket won’t affect the results on the field. I know it’s not worth maintaining this infantile contrarian facade that was just meant to help me fit in. I know sports fandom is merely a means for pale navel-gazing nerds to watch a thousand concurrent rolls of the dice and infer causality from the intensity of their cheering.
This team shouldn’t keep coaxing me back despite everything they’ve done to hurt me; this is addiction in its platonic form. After all the hours I’ve wasted lamenting defeats both heartbreaking and heart-shaking, I should finally stop investing in something that cares so little about me in return.
During each particularly pathetic losing streak, the time rolls around for me to renounce the Angels and, at long last, take the path more travelled. I don’t even need it anymore! I’ve already solidified my niche as a bit of an oddball. I write comedy to clamor for my friends’ attention, and I now have a whole posse to humor me and my self-indulgent interests. I’m finally holding my own. The time is ripe to abandon this burden and tell my kids the Angels thing was just a phase, not unlike my amateurish quarantine-era rap beats.
But quitting is hard. As toxic as it may be, the sheer level of loyalty I’ve poured into the Angels cedes yet another point to the sunk-cost fallacy. I can’t give up now — too many hours have been spent condoning a crisis of conceded control. The moment I splurged on a game-used jersey of #37 Kevin Padlo two years ago, I knew there was no turning back. Padlo, the benchwarmer’s benchwarmer, went 1-for-8 in a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it stint for the Angels back in 2023. I doubt even his own mom would remember he played for the team.
As I tossed away my receipt, it hit me that this jersey was just another strategy to beg for a vacuous validation, to relay Padlo’s comically uninteresting tenure to a potential onlooker. Were I to wear it, I’d be that same pathetic seven-year-old, sitting by the monkey bars, just waiting for the chance to bring up J.B. Shuck.
To this day, I’ve never worn the jersey. Not even in the privacy of my dorm room.
Cyrus P. Sarfaty ’29, a Crimson Editorial editor, is a Government concentrator in Adams House.
