Students Too Uptight

DISSENT

The staff's criticism of grade inflation illustrates one of the most annoying facets of the Harvard experience--dealing with uptight, hyper-competitive undergraduates. The reason that some Harvard students seethe about "the mires of grade inflation" is because high achievement by most of the student body robs them of a perverse pleasure that they have grown accustomed to enjoying. That is, many undergraduates cannot feel happy unless they are demonstrating that they are somehow superior to others.

The staff claims that grade inflation hampers "employers who are trying to distinguish among candidates," ignoring obvious measures such as interviews. Their argument is even more ridiculous considering the overwhelming advantages that most Harvard students already have when they decide to enter the workplace or pursue post-graduate studies. Is grade inflation really preventing more Harvard graduates from seizing the best jobs on Wall Street?

One of the explanations for grade inflation is that this student body has become increasingly talented and diverse. When Harvard used to be little more than a finishing school for the sons of New England's old money families, many undergraduates were satisfied with the "gentleman's C."

It is disturbing for a student newspaper to criticize a policy that benefits students. It seems that opponents of grade inflation would like their classes curved around a B- or a even a C. Their hubris prevents them from realizing that if such harsher grading policies were instituted, they would not necessarily benefit.

Recommended Articles

Law School Curbs Honors Correctly
A s Harvard College continues to flounder in the mires of grade inflation, we applaud the Law School for setting
Let It Bleed
There is no question that grades are on the rise in America, and have been for years. A report out
Harvey "C-plus" Mansfield?
Students: If you were scared away from Government 1061: "The History of Modern Political Philosophy" by the despotic grading of
To Deflate Grades, Eliminate the Core
With all the talk of late about grade inflation, it seems worthwhile to investigate the possible origins of whatever grade
Shoddy Scholarship
HYPOTHETICAL SITUATION: A student is assigned a paper on Machiavelli's indirect government. The student turns in a paper with the
Educational 'Therapy'
President Rudenstine has given his response to the recent controversy over grade inflation. To comfort his people, our wary President