When Harvard College created a lottery in 1995 to assign students to the upperclass Houses, it sought to end the exclusivity that had turned some of its Houses into jock dorms and others into elite enclaves.
But the spirit of randomization will never fully be realized so long as the College permits Houses to use Interhouse restrictions to keep non-residents out of their dining halls during peak hours.
In recent editions of House newsletters--including Fish Tales, Cabot House's weekly newsletter--the folks from Adams House have been kind enough to remind Quadlings that the Adams dining hall is indeed open to students from any House --just only during the least popular times to eat. During popular meal hours, however, we were gently reminded to stay out.
Other Houses--including Lowell, Winthrop, Eliot and Kirkland--also erected these barriers in recent years after FAS-funded, multi-million-dollar renovations to their dining halls made them extremely popular.
During my tenure as The Crimson's reporter for issues of House life, I wrote about the topic of Interhouse restrictions from time to time and had a chance to ask House residents why they supported these restrictions. The masters and House committee leaders I spoke to felt that dining halls that were crowded by non-residents made it tough for House residents to get a seat, thereby discouraging the creation of House community.
Although I am sympathetic to their concerns, I have a message for those Houses afflicted with popular dining halls: tough luck. Maintaining Interhouse restrictions is unfair, disproportionately hurts Quad residents and has no place in a randomized housing environment. And whereas, say, the law school can theoretically restrict the use of its library by College students because it is a different school altogether, one House should not be able to put a "keep out" sign on common College resources.
Under randomization, students are randomly assigned to Houses with the understanding that each House will be roughly similar to the others. That said, there are plusses and minuses to each House. Cabot, for instance, offers palatial rooms but is quite far from the center of campus. Adams, blessed with a superior location and a cushy dining hall, attracts lots of students at mealtime.
Not only is it mean-spirited and exclusive to keep non-residents out of certain House dining halls, but from an economic standpoint, it is also unfair. The money that the College and Harvard Dining Service spend on House dining halls comes from a pool of money collected from all students.
Inter-House WarfareLast year it was the gong--this year it is tiny white stickers. The interhouse brouhaha is back, and once again
The Harmonious FeastAlthough Harvard University is a unit in every legal and public sense, its members cannot generally meet each other at
Segregated DiningOn the Thursday morning before spring break, letters distributed throughout the Yard determined where 1,600 first-years would spend the greater
Vanity FareWith its dining hall already the most notorious on campus for turning away hungry outsiders because of its draconian interhouse
Freshmen for DinnerSome freshmen pick their House by the color of its tower. Others have more substantial criteria, but too many choose
We Must Protect This HouseNow that Quincy House has slapped interhouse dining restrictions on its dining hall—by banning first-years at dinner—it might want to