The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, unveiled by Republican lawmakers Nov. 2, includes a provision that would set an excise tax of 1.4 percent on the investment income of private colleges and universities that have at least 500 students and assets totaling $100,000 or more per full-time student. If the tax was in place for fiscal year 2017, Faust estimates Harvard would have handed over nearly $43 million to the federal government—funds she say would otherwise be spent funding Harvard’s research efforts or bolstering financial aid.
“It seems to us a blow at the strength of American higher education, the excellence of American higher education, and the competitiveness of American higher education,” Faust said. “At a time when, around the world there’s an investment in higher education, why would you put a tax on it?”
Last Thursday’s proposal marks a renewed effort by legislators to tap large university endowments for federal funds. In 2016, several senators began to consider whether universities boasting endowments with values of $1 billion or more should be taxed. Faust fiercely fought the proposal at the time, and it remains one of the University’s top lobbying priorities.
Faust said Thursday’s announcement was particularly “dispiriting” in light of past lobbying efforts, which included penning a letter to lawmakers explaining the purpose of Harvard’s endowment and repeated trips to the Capitol.
“I was on the Hill a lot last winter and was assured by a number of members of Congress that they were not considering an endowment tax, that they did not think it was a good idea,” Faust said. “And now those same people seem to be supporting it.”
Aside from requiring Harvard to hand over money each year, the tax might discourage potential donors from giving their money to the University. If the government taxes the endowment, Faust said donors might instead elect to fund other charitable organizations that will remain tax-exempt, like hospitals or scientific research foundations.
Several other measures in the wide-ranging tax bill, one of Republican lawmakers’ primary legislative priorities, could make higher education more expensive for some students and further threaten Harvard’s ability to attract donations.
The Tax Cut and Jobs Act restructures how individuals can claim tax deductions, potentially disincentivizing charitable giving to institutions like Harvard.
Three other provisions in the tax proposal directly impact how students pay tuition. The bill treats graduate student tuition waivers as taxable income and eliminates the tax deduction for interest on student loans. The bill also targets subsidies meant for employees who want to take classes through their employers.
Faust said the proposed changes lack “policy logic,” adding that she is actively lobbying lawmakers to oppose them.
“We have been working assiduously to make our case with people in Congress and use alumni who have connections with members of Congress to express their views, and to try to make clear why this would be such a destructive set of measures,” Faust said.
The tax plan is one of several federal policy changes that Harvard has actively fought in the last year. In particular, Faust has made a series of statements opposing changes in immigration policy, reductions to federal research funding, and the introduction of a ban on transgender service members in the military.
—Staff writer Brandon J. Dixon can be reached at email@example.com. Follow him on Twitter @BrandonJoDixon.
Mind Over MoneyWe believe that the money can be used for greater good at institutions of higher learning, and therefore believe that their financial well-being should be prioritized over that of corporations, at least in this situation.
Faust Lobbies Against GOP Tax Bill in D.C.
Hindering Higher EducationWe are extremely disappointed with this provision of the House’s tax plan. It disproportionately harms graduate students across the country who contribute knowledge, teaching, and labor to our educational institutions.
Faust Names GOP Tax Plan Top Lobbying Priority
End the Endowment TaxThe endowment tax is a calculated disregard for the important role of research in American society at a time when even facts are under constant attack by our leaders.