Advice to Josh: How To Cope With the Strikes
Josh is FM’s perpetually confused freshman, and this week, his classes and sections were cancelled due to the simultaneous non-tenure-track faculty and graduate student union strikes. What is going on, and what should he be doing with all his free time? Josh is turning to FM for some expert advice.
Josh, I regret to inform you that you have stumbled into the world’s most expensive independent study program. Your lecturers (temporarily) vanished, your sections have dissolved, and the only remaining evidence that you attend an institution of higher learning is a bill for $91,634. Think of yourself as a nineteenth-century gentleman scholar, free to pursue knowledge at your own pace, unencumbered by such vulgar modern inventions as attendance policies or pedagogical instruction. Spend your afternoons reading philosophy in Harvard Yard. Take up (performative) smoking. Write a manifesto. You may emerge from this experience with no transferable skills, but at least you’ll be qualified to teach in the humanities.
As for your grades, I suggest you take this opportunity to reflect on the fundamentally arbitrary nature of academic evaluation. What is an A, really? A letter. A social construct. A bourgeois invention designed to quantify the unquantifiable. Unfortunately, Josh, your future employer may not share this interpretation: do the readings.
—Filiz E. Fish
Should Josh keep doing his homework? Consider the facts, Josh. Your Expos preceptor was on the picket line. Your TF is still on the picket line. The University has promised to keep up “continuity in teaching, learning, and research,” and you may notice that the list doesn’t include grading. So your math psets are a litter of Schrödinger’s cats: each one graded and ungraded at once, until the day they all come back in one big avalanche of Canvas notifications. My advice is to keep doing the reading, but in keeping with the pace of negotiations: slowly, over at least two years, with lingering gaps on core issues. Raise your effort by 3.5 percent across the board — maybe 7 percent. Your roommate will point out that’s barely a raise given the effort you’d have put in anyway.
—X. Vanessa Huang
Josh, you’re probably wondering whether you should tell your parents that half your classes are cancelled and you have way too much time on your hands. I’ll be honest with you: They already know. Your mom has set a Google Alert for “Harvard” and her coworker has read every Harvard Crimson article remotely related to unions, from op-eds to FlyBy pieces. Your dad saw the Boston Globe article last week and sent it to your entire extended family’s WhatsApp chat. The real question isn’t to tell, or not to tell. It’s can you, or can you not intercept their letter of complaint to Alan Garber before it gets to Massachusetts Hall. (You can’t. That’s a federal crime.) My advice is to get ahead of it. Call home this evening and tell them everything is fine. Your grades are fine. You’re working harder than ever, and a Harvard education still means something, at least to you. You will, in fact, get a job with paid time off someday. Then tell them you’re headed to Lamont and hang up before they ask what you’ve been doing with all your free time.
—Sania Grewal
Josh, make sure to support the strikes as much as you can. After all, where else would you find this many graduate students all together in one place? Bring your curriculum vitae and ask for advice on your grad school applications. Ask whoever’s leading the chants if they’re taking undergraduate research assistants. And even if they aren’t, offer to hold a sign. It’s basically a poster presentation, except it’s about fair contracts. Just make sure that your support isn’t too helpful, because if the strikes succeed before December, Professor of Philosophy Susanna Rinard just might have enough graders to give you that Happiness final after all.
—Sophia C. Guild
In 1969, John Lennon and Yoko Ono stayed in bed for a week to protest the Vietnam War. The press flooded the couple’s bedroom daily to photograph the couple’s nonviolent resistance. Josh, should you, too, feel the urge to protest the bargaining war between our teaching staff and University administration, I suggest you follow John and Yoko’s example. The Crimson needs something new to cover.
—Magazine writer Victoria L. Dolan can be reached at [email protected].
Josh, you should’ve seduced your teaching fellow. It’s too late to pine for salacious study sessions or after-hours office hours, but maybe there’s still hope for your Math 1b midterm. I know the temptation to doomscroll at the back of your math section (temporarily combined into one giant math lecture) is strong, but remember, you need to get on the last-standing TFs’ good side. They’re not only getting suboptimal pay, but their workload now includes babysitting the countless strike refugees pouring into their lessons. Maybe include a love note in your next pset submission.
This applies to Expos, too. Yes, your classroom might be empty, but you should still show up. With how volatile the grade cap already is, to be one of the three As in your class, you have to cover all your bases. You never know; Harvard could always conduct random spot checks. If the strike isn’t resolved by the end of the semester, your A might genuinely depend on your attendance records, or worse: retaking Expos.
On a serious note, don’t seduce your TF. If the strike is successful, you might find yourself in a Title IX case against a much better-protected union worker.
—Sophie Y.S. Chong
Perhaps the solution is simply to end inflation, freeze rents, provide free universal daycare, and cure workplaces of harassment. You’re a Harvard student, Josh, and you’re probably taking Economics 10. You can do anything.
—Associate Magazine Editor Megha Khemka can be reached at [email protected].
Josh, there’s a good chance you’re planning to be an economics concentrator. I’m going to assume you are (I know I plan to be). So let’s be rational economic agents here.
With classes and sections cancelled, you will undoubtedly have more free time. Now consider the opportunity cost of spending that time on work. Josh — you could be out exploring Boston. Have you ever considered how much time you actually spend in the closed off bubble that is Harvard? Yes, you go to a small liberal arts school just outside of Boston, but let’s not make that our personality, shall we? Instead — explore Boston Common, eat food in Chinatown, visit cool museums! Understand that you’re also building a stock of knowledge for the future: after you’ve settled down at Wall Street, your friends will want to reap the benefits of knowing a Harvard graduate. When you make a trip back to Boston, they’ll assume you know the place. It’ll be a disgrace if you don’t.
Plus, you’ll never have this free time again once you start recruiting. And consider the spillover effects of doing homework — what if it doesn’t get graded? What if you’re the only one who does it, and you look like a nerd? Objectively, your utility from knowing Boston is greater than that from any work you could do.
—Victoria X. Woo
O Josh, how similar the chants of strikers are to the school bells of your youth, both announcing math class in rhythmic percussion. Now as you enter Zimmer Hall, you consider, in the spirit of your secret idol Terence Fletcher, ‘are the drumming strikers rushing or dragging’? And above all, is this new atmosphere quite ‘your tempo’? Before you throw chairs, and take any “Whiplash” analogy too far, listen closely. You must embrace that initial musical curiosity, not the histrionics. Find the music, wherever you go. Rely on rhythms of consistency — the constants in your life like psets, homework, friends, upcoming holidays. Capitalize on the expected in this tumultuous time, O Josh. Now, you say some of your classes do not run all the time. Consider replacing that time with actual music. Exercise your free will in a musically themed strut across campus, put on your headphones, and live for a few minutes in a soundtracked-montage. For the much more spiritually grounded days, sway to the chorus of the wind or rain as it streams through the Yard. O Josh, your passion and zeal get the best of you sometimes, but I urge you to stay grounded.
—Camila E. Carreon
I’m sorry, Josh, but I just don’t think the union needs a beatboxer.
—Associate Magazine Editor Wyatt J. Meyer can be reached at [email protected].
