Most Mysterious: Annushka Agarwal
I ask Annushka why she thinks she is Most Mysterious. “It’s a strange superlative,” she says. “The people on campus who are really mysterious are probably not being voted Most Mysterious, because people don’t know who they are.”
Annushka Agarwal ’27 keeps a list of quotes she likes on her Goodreads page. One is by American novelist John Steinbeck: “I wonder how many people I’ve looked at all my life and never seen.”
When I first sit down to talk to Annushka, the Class of 2027’s Most Mysterious senior, she’s tucked away at a corner table in the Kirkland dining hall. She’s wearing a burnt orange sweater on top of a teal layering shirt, with her hair in a messy topknot. Her glasses are off, hooked on her collar; every once in a while, she takes them off and fidgets with them.
I start by asking Annushka to describe herself — she tells me she is from Vancouver, that she is studying history and math, and that she is in Kirkland, but doesn’t supply much more. She pauses after every sentence, leaving me wondering if she has more to say, or if I’m letting awkward silence fill the room for too long.
I ask Annushka, a former Crimson Editorial editor and current News editor, why she thinks she is Most Mysterious.“It’s a strange superlative,” she says. “The people on campus who are really mysterious are probably not being voted Most Mysterious, because people don’t know who they are.”
But getting to know Annushka is no easy task either; she dodges many of my questions.
We discuss an op-ed Annushka wrote as a member of The Crimson’s Editorial board, in which she described people who pretend that they’ve done their section readings as playing a game of Mafia. I ask if she had ever played mafia during section — “no comment.” I ask whether Annushka ever hid behind the kind of ornate academic language that she describes her peers using as they try to be specific about the reading they’ve never read — but not so specific that they say something wrong. “Not deliberately,” she says. But Annushka concedes that talking in an academic register can make a conversation feel more removed. “There’s more distance,” she adds.
I can’t get a sense for whether Annushka is intentionally being elusive, or whether she feels like she doesn’t have a lot to say. Annushka says she would not describe herself as an opinionated person, mostly. But, I ask, why does someone who isn’t particularly opinionated decide to join The Crimson’s Editorial Board, of all places?
“One thing that’s frustrating about Harvard is feeling like I care a lot about certain things that other people don’t care about at all,” Annushka answers. “I think it’s nice to be reminded sometimes that there are things that other people care about a lot that I don’t care about at all.”
So, I push: what does she feel strongly about that other people don’t?
“I’m gonna get a cup of tea,” she says, rising.
Three minutes later, Annushka returns with a mug of Earl Grey and a splash of milk. The bag has barely steeped; she is quite sensitive to caffeine, she tells me, and it is late in the day. Annushka wonders aloud who the Earl Grey had been. She could look it up, she says, but she likes the mystery.
I try to get her back on track to the question I asked her earlier — what does Annushka feel strongly about that other people might not care about? This time, she opens up. “I don’t think people here care adequately about the social impact that their careers will have,” she says carefully.
It is, she admits, “a banal opinion that is difficult to articulate in a way that isn’t moralizing.” But it is also a window into some of the questions that occupy her: whether the ways we organize our lives are as inevitable as we assume, how societies decide what matters, and why people become insensitive to the suffering of other living things.
Earlier in our conversation, Annushka had expressed to me her love of the ocean. She described hiking through Juan de Fuca Provincial Park, which winds along the coast of Vancouver Island. At Botanical Beach, also in the park, she tells me how she and her friends once encountered a giant Pacific octopus in a tide pool.
But her favorite marine animals are whales — orcas, in particular. (In 2019, Annushka named her blog “Agarwhale” after the sea creatures.) Last summer, while hiking on Vancouver Island, she and a friend stopped on a rock overlooking the water and watched a pod swim by, within 10 meters of where they stood. She remembers their size, but also their skin, encrusted with barnacles and algae. Their bodies, she explains, are habitats for other organisms.
The ocean seems like an apt subject for Annushka; it is, after all, one of the world’s more familiar mysteries — even though the ocean covers 70 percent of the earth, we’ve explored less than 5 percent of it.
After a sophomore-year imperial history seminar, Annushka became interested in commercial whaling. Having depleted the whaling grounds further south, some whalers moved into the Arctic, where they established remote outposts and often stayed through the winter to take advantage of consecutive whaling seasons. Their presence brought them into contact with Inuit communities, whose members sometimes rescued shipwrecked whalers, fed them, and helped them survive the winter. (Her senior History thesis follows from this interest, examining the relationships between the Inuit community and the workers stationed at the Distant Early Warning Line, a network of Cold War radar stations in the Arctic.)
Annushka was struck by the violence at the center of the history between the whalers and the Inuit. “The commercial whalers are doing something really cruel and destructive at some level, right? Which is that they are slaughtering creatures that are highly sensitive, that have developed nervous systems, not because they need to do it personally, but because it’s lucrative,” she tells me. “I think there’s this question of – why do some people retain sensitivity to other beings and other people don’t?”
“I don’t think I found a good answer to that question, but it’s very interesting to me.”
At the beginning of the semester, a mouse snuck into her suite’s common room and was caught in a trap. Though she was unhappy with the mouse’s presence, Annushka found herself troubled by what to do with its body. She considered putting it in a plastic bag and throwing it in the trash, but found that an “ethically unsettling way to deal with a dead body.”
“She has a very strong moral compass,” adds Ericka Lai ’27, her suitemate. “Out of everyone I know, like, one of the strongest moral compasses.”
I’ve only been speaking with Annushka for 90 minutes, but her passion for whales — and what it suggests about her moral compass — tell me much more about her character than a simple Harvard intro ever could.
The mystery of Annushka, I think, is not that her thoughts and beliefs are inscrutable; it is that the things she cares about, and the intensity with which she considers them, take time to understand.
— Magazine writer Sarit O. Greenwood can be reached at [email protected].
