Most Herself: Yona Sperling-Milner
This is about Yona, who goes by a number of names.
[In the Jewish esoteric tradition,] each consonant of the word PaRDeS denotes one of the levels [of scriptural interpretation]: P stands for peshat, the literal meaning, R for remez the allegorical meaning, D for derasha, the Talmudic [normative] and Aggadic [narrative], S for sod, the mystical meaning.
—Gershom Scholem, On the Kabbalah and Its Symbolism, trans. Ralph Manheim (Schocken, 1965), 57.
P
Yona was born on April 16, 2004, about a week ahead of schedule. This is because Yona has always been a go-getter.
Yona uses she/her/hers pronouns. This is because she is a woman.
Yona is an observant Jew. I wouldn’t mention it, except the whole Jew-y thing going on in this piece doesn’t really make sense if you don’t know that. I am also Jewish. Not that this is about me.
Yona has two sisters and a brother. Her mom is a rabbi and her dad is an immunologist. This is not about them either.
This is about Yona, who goes by a number of names. To her high school acquaintances, she was YSM. To The Harvard Crimson, she is Yona T. Sperling-Milner ’27. To CNN (live on air), she was YO-nuh (stress on the first syllable, rhymes with Jonah). Here (and usually) she is Yona, stress on the second syllable. It means “dove.”
Yona grew up around Washington, D.C. She attended Melvin J. Berman Hebrew Academy until fourth grade, when her parents switched her to another Jewish day school. Milton Gottesman Jewish Day School of the Nation’s Capital calls itself “an independent Jewish day school in DC distinguished by its commitment to academic excellence, talented faculty, and learning that is joyful, engaging, hands-on, and enduring.” Yona describes it as “happy, clappy lib school.”
Between seventh and 10th grade, Yona switched schools four times in four years, eventually landing at SAR High School, a Modern Orthodox private school in New York City. The school motto is “it’s not just what you learn. It’s who you become.” (Writer’s note: Remember that process of becoming; it comes back later.)
Throughout her time at SAR, she organized “insane, ridiculous, shticky, things all the time,” Yona Sperling-Milner tells me, such as founding the Hyphenated-Last-Name Support Group for others afflicted by her debilitating (and inherited) condition. Their meetings featured lots of Coca-Cola and Cheez-Its.
At the end of 10th grade, the whole COVID thing happened. Yona watched ducks and organized a family election. She ran for “mother” and won. For the rest of high school, she made all her family’s big decisions.
Since she’s abdicated that post, her maternal instinct, “doesn’t have such an outlet outside of buying yogurt for the post-minyan breakfast crowd.” She is very good at this: Skyr for one person, less sugar for another, nut-free Chobani flips if she can find them.
(MOST HERSELF is almost an anagram of MOTHERLESS. Yona is very good at Bananagrams.)
Right before coming to Harvard, Yona took a gap year to attend seminary, which is “like a monastery where you only live for one year,” to study Jewish law and traditions, at the very intense Migdal Oz.
“Seminary also made me a lot more spiritual,” Yona says. “Before I was like, ugh, I hate poetry; Chassidus [roughly, ‘spiritualism’] is for losers, whatever. Now I love poetry and Chassidus.”
When she got to Harvard, she was “very, very happy overall” but let down by the general dearth of moral worth. “Everyone’s gonna have such amazing values,” she thought, before quickly learning upon arrival that “no,” people here “just have fewer values and less of it going around, unless they’re religious in some way or another.”
By March of her first year, she wanted out of Harvard. She eventually escaped through a study abroad program at Jesus College at the other Cambridge in her junior spring.
In the meantime, she still found or created spaces to fill the value void here at Godless University: Jewish-Christian Bible Study (“it’s like a WWE fight, but instead of putting people in chokeholds we read, discuss, and productively disagree about biblical passages,” Yona advertised through the Interfaith newsletter), a “God Salon” that met weekly to discuss existential questions, and many meetings with Mormons.
When she found Jesus (College), she also found a “completely new start.” Her strategy, she tells me, “very quickly became to just be radically transparent about everything.” For those back home, she sent updates on a WhatsApp chat appropriately called “Jesus, Yona.”
Yona sympathizes with the effective altruists and encourages people to donate at www.givewell.org, but she is less a utilitarian than a Kantian.
Most recently, Yona got into a spat on X with a Substacker/sex worker/amateur statistician about whether the categorical imperative denies sexually deviant women agency.
In conclusion, Merriam-Webster defines “self” as “the union of elements (such as body, emotions, thoughts, and sensations) that constitute the individuality and identity of a person.” Yona is the most that.
R
The gematria — a Hebrew numerological method used to find hidden allegorical meanings — of “Yona Tiferet Sperling-Milner” is 1915, the same year Albert Einstein arrived at the field equations of his theory of general relativity.
What are we to learn from this? Just as general relativity revealed that the force of gravity was not a force at all, but the curvature of space-time itself, so too are things not what they appear with Yona Tiferet Sperling-Milner.
Would the Most Herself senior in all of Harvard University wear fake glasses? Lying about one’s ocular acumen doesn’t exactly appear the acme of authenticity. Yet the world through Yona’s lenses is utterly undistorted.
In fact, if you squint, it becomes difficult to understand how Yona possibly won this superlative in the first place.
For one, she is best known around campus and around the world for the biting satire she originally published in a column titled “A School Outside Boston.”
Through the column and subsequent satirical op-eds published in The Crimson, Yona commented on whatever was in the Harvard student zeitgeist: an antisemitic cartoon, Harvard’s outsized media coverage, the Trump administration’s attacks on the University, or Halloween.
In one piece titled “Stop Complaining About the Laundry Prices, You Unpatriotic Cheapskate,” she wrote what some people (me) are calling the greatest opening grafs in Crimson history, worth quoting in full here:
“I wake up in the morning in a cold sweat. Good — that means I can do some more laundry. I sprint downstairs with my pajamas in tow and stuff it all into the machine. Slowly, reverently, I open the One Tap Away app and thank my lucky stars I have the privilege of stocking the coffers of the university I hold so dear.
25 cents down. $2.7 billion to go.”
Yet, is satire not the very opposite of true self-expression? One expresses what is not true, what is absurdly not true. And even if satire indirectly articulates real underlying beliefs, the humor provides a mask to hide behind. Yona started writing satire at The Crimson because she felt she was “not smart enough or bossy enough to have real opinions.”
And for someone who is supposedly so herself, Yona sure spends a lot of time thinking about playing characters. She is uber-aware of the code-switching she does constantly — between secular and religious circles, close friends and interviewers, when speaking to men or women.
She talks again and again about taking up certain moral positions not because she believes them in any abstract sense, but only because others expect her to espouse them. She sometimes takes actions only because she says she wants “better content for the Yona-character I am constantly constructing.”
Or, at other times, Yona admits she’s often defined herself in opposition to whatever environment she was in.
In these cases, Yona seems not like an active self, but like a passive reflection or mirroring of others: Not Most Herself, it seems, but Most Her Surroundings.
As Amelia M. Heller ’27 phrased it on the “Who is Yona?” form (more on that in the derasha), Yona can sometimes feel “trapped by her Yona-ness and in feeling like she has to perform the self in various different groups by asserting her intellectual, comedic, or maternal dominance.” “This is,” Amelia says, “the most Yona thing ever.”
Yona puts a more positive spin on things. Every moment, every setting is the opportunity to ask, “Who will I choose to become in this moment?” And is “becoming,” she says, not “the most fun, most important, most exciting thing?”
We tend to think of the self as an entity distinct from and prior to our actions and behaviors. Under this framework, it really does make no sense for Yona to have won Most Herself. The real Most Herself would be utterly unreflective, just doing her own thing, paying no mind to her own mind or the world around her. She would not wear fake glasses, write satire, or spend any time attempting to define herself.
But this is not how Yona sees the world. The self is an active construction site — maybe not a tabula rasa, but a slate that’s pretty damn blank.
The characters we choose to become — either to fit into or in opposition to our environments — are not the products of ourselves multiplied by our surroundings. Instead, the characters shape our selves.
“If you groove certain actions and habits into yourself deep enough, it eventually does become your character,” Yona says. “In Judaism, we say ‘shelo lishma, bah lishmah,’ ‘that which is not for its own sake, becomes for its own sake.’”
And self-reflection, rather than destroying authentic spontaneity, becomes authenticity itself in Yona-land.
A realization, for example, that her existential angst did not have a philosophical cause, but a biological one, did not end her sense of self and free-will. In fact, this crisis became the new environment around which she now constructs her self. Today, Yona is writing her senior thesis on “moral steroids,” drugs like adderall and SSRIs that she argues may help one to be a better moral agent but which seem to circumvent the more important goal of becoming a better moral agent through one’s own actions.
So Yona is not just Yona T. Sperling Milner ’27, the satire writer for The Crimson Ed Board. Yona is not just YSM, the shtick-maker and comedian provocateur.
Yona is the actress who chooses to play these characters just as she is the creation of the characters she has played.
Yona is herself precisely because she wrestles with herself, with every version of herself.
Yona is Yona. And “Yona” in gematria is 71, the same as kamoha, which could be translated from Hebrew as “like herself.” Yona is therefore literally, mathematically, symbolically, like herself.
Maybe even the Most Herself.
D
Reb Zusha of Anipoli supposedly told his disciples a story that Yona repeats to me at the end of our second interview. “When you go up to heaven,” as Yona tells it, “God’s not gonna ask you ‘why weren’t you like Abraham, why weren’t you Isaac, or why aren’t you Jacob?’” Instead, God will ask, why weren’t you yourself?
The point is well taken; none of us — save Yona — should strive to be Most Yona. To do so would be absurd. Eliana Goldin, a close friend of Yona’s, calls her “one of the few people who really is not replicable.”
So if the story of Yona shouldn’t teach us how to be Yona, what should it teach us?
With absolutely zero prompting, Goldin sent a form to Yona’s closest friends and family and promised me that she would “have Claude analyze the results” (luckily for me, the raw data was also available undigested). The form was titled “Who is Yona?” but the answers hinted at a different question: Who does Yona make those around her?
Yona-infected people — per the survey responses — tend to come away more complicated. She “doesn’t accept simple or cop-out answers” from those around her. She is “blunt.” She makes those around her “hopeful” just as she can make them confused.
“Meeting Yona,” Goldin tells me, “is a very visceral experience for many.”
This was certainly true in my own conversations with Yona. She constantly made me zoom out from quotidian particulars into her own world of values and ethics and Being (often by means of a near-exact quotation from a philosopher or writer who happened to be on her mind).
As one anonymous respondent to “Who is Yona?” put it, Yona “makes me a better me.”
Yona is worried this whole piece will come off as hopelessly egotistical — like eulogizing someone still alive. “Most herself” might as well have been “most special snowflake,” she says.
But if this profile has conveyed even a sliver of Yona, it will be more than a testament to her vanity. For, since Yona’s friends and family have learned from her to be more thoughtful, interesting, but still grounded people, perhaps you, dear reader, may learn the same.
Yona changed the way Goldin sees the world. “I’ve put on my Yona glasses,” Goldin tells me, “and I don’t ever plan on taking them off.”
I wonder whether these glasses, like Yona’s, are fake.
S
2 Yona 23:34: “Life is art, you’re writing the self as a character, and it’s just however you choose to write the character, such that it is read.”
1 Yona 68:58: “I remember one girl who’s very, very smart and said, ‘yeah, I definitely don’t believe in God, but what can I do? I feel Him all the time.’”
1 Yona 11:39: “When I was a little kid, I was quite bothered by — I don’t know — divine omniscience. I would be sitting on the floor in my living room, and then I’d throw my hands up in the air, or do something really, really random. I was trying to do an uncaused action that God wouldn’t expect … I would still say that one of my primary goals in life is uncaused action, but it doesn’t have to be uncaused, right? It just has to be under-determined.”
1 Yona 77:51: “Another thing that used to be taped to my wall: ‘May it be the real “I” who speaks. May it be the real “Thou” I speak to.’”
2 Yona 57:37: “The hard work of becoming is not done in a day.”
—Magazine writer Henry G. Levenson can be reached at [email protected].
