News

The New Gen Ed Lottery System, Explained

News

Armed Individuals Sighted in Harvard Square Arraigned

News

Harvard Students Form Coalition Supporting Slave Photo Lawsuit's Demands

News

Police Apprehend Armed Man and Woman in Central Square

News

107 Faculty Called for Review of Tenure Procedures in Letter to Dean Gay

Council Chair Election Race In Dead Heat

News Analysis

By D. RICHARD De silva and Ivy A. Wang

Undergraduate Council members Michael P. Beys '94, Vice Chair Steven N. Kalkanis '93, and Rico Reyes '93--all of whom have lost major council elections--know what it means to see their political lives flash before their eyes.

Nevertheless, all are back this week and campaigning furiously for the council's highest office. In the last few days, they have been locked in one of the most intense races for chair in recent years.

Sunday's election ultimately appears to rest less on the issues and more on the characters and records of the candidates. It is also another showdown between two factions that have dominated the council in recent years.

"I think this is going to be the most interesting race since I've been here...because of the personalities involved," said former chair David A. Aronberg '93.

Beys and Kalkanis seem to be in a dead heat, while council members say Reyes has little chance to pull off an upset in Sunday's elections.

Different Products

Beyond their mutual flirtation with political oblivion, Beys and Kalkanis represent totally different products of the same council.

Beys rose through the ranks of the finance committee. Kalkanis found his niche in the academics and then the services committees. He has organized concerts and social events while Kalkanis has pursued calendar reform and concentration fairs.

Beys is a dynamic, hands-on politician who has served as former treasurer and chair of the influential finance committee. Last fall, he lost a bid for vice chair to Maya G. Prabhu '94.

Beys has come under fire for his involvement in organizing concerts. In February 1992, the council endorsed a privately organized Spin Doctors concert at Beys' bidding. The concert was successful and Beys received the praise of the 300 persons in attendance, but he was criticized for using the council's resources to help his friends, who had organized the event.

Beys was also one of the organizers of the De La Soul concert last spring, which lost in excess of $10,000.

Though Beys was one of several organizers, he still takes responsibility for the mistakes that led up to the concert. "We learned a lot of lessons in De La Soul," he said. "Mistakes were made. Mistakes we learned from. I took the blame, I took the responsibility. I do it to this day."

At the time, Beys also fought off an attempt to impeach him.

Beys' supporters say that he gets the job done and is willing to put his neck on the line--a rare quality among skittish undergraduate politicians--to organize events for students. Critics say Beys short-circuits the democratic process of the council to further his own career.

Kalkanis comes from the old school of former chairs Evan Rauch '91 and Robert C. Rhew '92. Rauch and Rhew ran councils that pushed strong student services agendas in a quiet, behind-the-scenes manner.

Kalkanis is a hard-working, elder statesman on the council. "The clearest difference is that I have the most experience in dealing with the student body at large and the administration," he said. "I've always tried to be open and inclusive."

He has chaired both the academic and services committees, and spear-headed wide-ranging reform of the calendar. He is an institutional man, faithful and reliable, but with little flash.

"I think Steve Kalkanis is a great candidate," said staunch Kalkanis supporter, David L. Duncan '93, who lost in the fall chair elections to Heinicke. "I think he is not only a hard worker, [but] he is [also] a perfectly respectable and trustworthy steward of the Undergraduate Council."

Kalkanis is a second-semester senior. Most chair candidates in the past have been juniors. The last second-semester senior who served as chair was Ken Lee '89, and several members expressed concern over a senior chair's ability to commit time to the council and ensure the continuity of the council between the spring and the fall.

Kalkanis and Reyes, who is also a senior, both said that they will be taking lighter courseloads than usual and will be able to devote their full attention to the council.

Kalkanis' agenda is typified by student-faculty committees and longer intersessions.

Beys pursues the bells and whistles: the concerts and the parties and high-profile efforts that have made his reputation and landed him in hot water.

In the last three elections, the Beys-Heinicke faction has won out. Aronberg best Kalkanis in fall 1992. Beys staved off Rhew's efforts to impeach him last spring. And with the departure of a large part of the Kalkanis-Rauch-Rhew faction last year, Heinicke won the fall election handily over Duncan.

But Kalkanis is a fighter. With the experience of a former campaign under his belt and a semester as vice chair healing the council's wounds from the Prabhu scandal, he is a formidable candidate.

Kalkanis said he has a definite edge over the other candidates. "I have very clear goals, but I also have the experience and plan to attain those goals."

By all accounts, Reyes is a dark horse candidate. Reyes has worked on the finance committee for four years. He has also served as the council's parliamentarian and chair of the finance committee.

As chair, Reyes said he can help motivate the council and work to improve student life.

"It should not be a council for the council, but a council for the students," said Reyes.

Apart from all the rhetoric and the factional battle-lines, however, the deciding votes will probably lie with the first-years on the council.

First-years interviewed yesterday said they may decide on Sunday's chair race on the basis of candidates' position papers and speeches.

Allison Weinberg '96 said that all the candidates appear equally active and responsible on the council, and that "its much harder for the freshmen to know them" to form other opinions regarding the candidates' characters.

Ultimately, it may be up to first-years like Weinberg to break a possible factional stalemate in Sunday's elections

Beys rose through the ranks of the finance committee. Kalkanis found his niche in the academics and then the services committees. He has organized concerts and social events while Kalkanis has pursued calendar reform and concentration fairs.

Beys is a dynamic, hands-on politician who has served as former treasurer and chair of the influential finance committee. Last fall, he lost a bid for vice chair to Maya G. Prabhu '94.

Beys has come under fire for his involvement in organizing concerts. In February 1992, the council endorsed a privately organized Spin Doctors concert at Beys' bidding. The concert was successful and Beys received the praise of the 300 persons in attendance, but he was criticized for using the council's resources to help his friends, who had organized the event.

Beys was also one of the organizers of the De La Soul concert last spring, which lost in excess of $10,000.

Though Beys was one of several organizers, he still takes responsibility for the mistakes that led up to the concert. "We learned a lot of lessons in De La Soul," he said. "Mistakes were made. Mistakes we learned from. I took the blame, I took the responsibility. I do it to this day."

At the time, Beys also fought off an attempt to impeach him.

Beys' supporters say that he gets the job done and is willing to put his neck on the line--a rare quality among skittish undergraduate politicians--to organize events for students. Critics say Beys short-circuits the democratic process of the council to further his own career.

Kalkanis comes from the old school of former chairs Evan Rauch '91 and Robert C. Rhew '92. Rauch and Rhew ran councils that pushed strong student services agendas in a quiet, behind-the-scenes manner.

Kalkanis is a hard-working, elder statesman on the council. "The clearest difference is that I have the most experience in dealing with the student body at large and the administration," he said. "I've always tried to be open and inclusive."

He has chaired both the academic and services committees, and spear-headed wide-ranging reform of the calendar. He is an institutional man, faithful and reliable, but with little flash.

"I think Steve Kalkanis is a great candidate," said staunch Kalkanis supporter, David L. Duncan '93, who lost in the fall chair elections to Heinicke. "I think he is not only a hard worker, [but] he is [also] a perfectly respectable and trustworthy steward of the Undergraduate Council."

Kalkanis is a second-semester senior. Most chair candidates in the past have been juniors. The last second-semester senior who served as chair was Ken Lee '89, and several members expressed concern over a senior chair's ability to commit time to the council and ensure the continuity of the council between the spring and the fall.

Kalkanis and Reyes, who is also a senior, both said that they will be taking lighter courseloads than usual and will be able to devote their full attention to the council.

Kalkanis' agenda is typified by student-faculty committees and longer intersessions.

Beys pursues the bells and whistles: the concerts and the parties and high-profile efforts that have made his reputation and landed him in hot water.

In the last three elections, the Beys-Heinicke faction has won out. Aronberg best Kalkanis in fall 1992. Beys staved off Rhew's efforts to impeach him last spring. And with the departure of a large part of the Kalkanis-Rauch-Rhew faction last year, Heinicke won the fall election handily over Duncan.

But Kalkanis is a fighter. With the experience of a former campaign under his belt and a semester as vice chair healing the council's wounds from the Prabhu scandal, he is a formidable candidate.

Kalkanis said he has a definite edge over the other candidates. "I have very clear goals, but I also have the experience and plan to attain those goals."

By all accounts, Reyes is a dark horse candidate. Reyes has worked on the finance committee for four years. He has also served as the council's parliamentarian and chair of the finance committee.

As chair, Reyes said he can help motivate the council and work to improve student life.

"It should not be a council for the council, but a council for the students," said Reyes.

Apart from all the rhetoric and the factional battle-lines, however, the deciding votes will probably lie with the first-years on the council.

First-years interviewed yesterday said they may decide on Sunday's chair race on the basis of candidates' position papers and speeches.

Allison Weinberg '96 said that all the candidates appear equally active and responsible on the council, and that "its much harder for the freshmen to know them" to form other opinions regarding the candidates' characters.

Ultimately, it may be up to first-years like Weinberg to break a possible factional stalemate in Sunday's elections

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.

Tags