To Produce Citizen-Leaders, Give Students a Seat at the Table
Go to thecrimson.com and search up “needs.” Based on the bazillion search results, it’s safe to say that we, Harvard students, certainly believe there is a lot Harvard needs to accomplish. But when was the last time you felt you could “do” something?
The Harvard College mission statement boldly states its vow to educate “citizen-leaders.” While it mentions “transformative” education as a pathway to that goal, many will agree that the making of citizen-leaders has another crucial aspect: training commitment to civic responsibility.
Yet ironically, the College seems all but unwilling to allow students the perusal of this value. In Harvard’s recently released survey of the Class of 2026, only 41.5 percent of graduating seniors were satisfied with administrative response to student concerns. In cases where students are the most direct stakeholders, I have yet to see any instance where our voice made a significant contribution to administrative decisions.
If Harvard truly wants to educate citizen-leaders, it should teach civic responsibility by building student representation into University governance. The failure of our current mechanisms for student involvement signals the importance of establishing new ones.
After faculty passed the infamous cap on A grades last spring, many undergraduates were left disgruntled as town halls meant to address student concerns failed to deliver any meaningful revisions.
Even in decisions purely concerning student experience, there is little jurisdiction or opportunity to provide input given to students. And decisions made at the sole discretion of the University hardly always seem the most agreeable.
The institutionalist approach to solving this power imbalance must be the incorporation of student leadership. This should take the form of a new University council with executive jurisdiction at the level of the Harvard Corporation under a shared governance framework.
But, skeptics might say to my call for student power, who out there wouldn’t mind having more authority than less? We probably wouldn’t mind going as far as choosing our own grades if given free rein. Also Harvard, as a private institution run by a corporation, has little incentive to give students such power. Yet as an institution of higher education that prides itself on training citizen-leaders, it has an obligation to do so.
If we look across the Atlantic, universities in the United Kingdom, including Oxford and Cambridge, have student representation on their university councils, their principal governing boards. Similar unitary or shared governance structures are in place in many European universities, sometimes with legal requirements for student involvement.
In some cases, these student representatives are elected by the student body and exercise direct voting power. Their involvement works as a counterbalance to university administration on issues where students are natural stakeholders.
At Harvard, instead of formal administrative representation, student opinion is voiced through advisory positions on student boards and committees. As for our elected student representation, the Harvard Undergraduate Association is a student government in name only: doing little beyond distributing student organization funds, planning the occasional event, and administering sporadic polling.
The other method of student-led persuasion that has historically found success in swaying university decisions is that of exercising our First Amendment rights — whether in opposition to the Vietnam War or for anti-apartheid divestment. But disruption and protests should not be the sole pathway for future citizen-leaders taking initiative to contribute to their institutions. Protests also tend to happen in response to issues of national outcry — not a sustainable framework for regular engagement.
A change in the status quo overnight or introducing mainstream student politics is not practical and can be harmful, but small changes to increase student involvement must take place. Opportunities to voice concerns or challenges in town halls or assemblies should take place throughout the policy decision-making process. The proposed faculty senate needs to have more than an advisory role in legislative jurisdiction, as faculty members are often an accessible gateway for student sentiment.
And eventually, whether through a direct democracy framework of student votes or having student representation on an administrative University council, we deserve a seat at the table that does justice to our role as stakeholders.
To those still not persuaded: With the grade cap looming large, the decisions we take as a wider community will decide if this can be a successful move towards academic recentering or if it becomes a disaster for student well-being, as it did at Princeton. The only way to ensure effectiveness is including student voices in the decisions they ultimately have to bear.
If Harvard can pay millions to McKinsey for advice on how to run itself, perhaps it can also give voice to the fundamental demographic — the students — that make it a University.
Adnan Bin Alamgir ’29, a Crimson Editorial editor, is a joint concentrator in Physics and Mathematics in Lowell House.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially