Advertisement
News

Harvard, Graduate Student Union Clash Over Picketing and Mediation Amid Strike


Members of the Harvard Graduate Students Union-UAW rally outside University Hall amid their strike.
Members of the Harvard Graduate Students Union-UAW rally outside University Hall amid their strike. | By Pavan V. Thakkar
By José Luis Ortega Castro, Crimson Staff Writer

Harvard’s graduate students returned to the bargaining table Tuesday after weeks of tension — occasionally verging on acrimony — between the striking workers and University administrators.

Since graduate students walked out on Oct. 27, administrators have accused the union of violating University policies on three occasions and alleged that a union negotiator made inappropriate remarks to members of the University bargaining team during their Nov. 5 bargaining session. The University has also proposed bringing in a third-party mediator.

Union officials have argued their actions on the picket line stayed within University policies, criticized the University for threatening disciplinary action, and framed mediation as a stalling tactic.

The Harvard Graduate Students Union-United Auto Workers, which represents more than 4,000 graduate and undergraduate student workers, entered Tuesday’s session still seeking higher wages and benefits, protections for noncitizen workers, and an independent process for harassment and discrimination complaints. HGSU-UAW and the University have agreed on nine proposals after more than 18 months of negotiations.

The Harvard Academic Workers-UAW, which joined HGSU-UAW on the picket line last Tuesday, also held a bargaining session Tuesday — its first since its strike began. Hours later, HAW-UAW members voted to end their weeklong strike and return to work Wednesday after Harvard doubled its proposed raise to 7 percent, though the two sides have yet to reach a contract. HGSU-UAW is now the only union on strike at Harvard.

Administrators have criticized the graduate student union in recent weeks for allegedly violating University policies.

Paul Curran, Harvard’s managing director of labor and employee relations, first alleged in a Nov. 4 letter that the union ran afoul of the University-wide Statement on Rights and Responsibilities and the Anti-Bullying Policy after it loudly disrupted an Oct. 29 midterm.

He claimed HGSU-UAW intentionally targeted the class — General Education 1116: “Medical Ethics and History” — because some of its teaching fellows had opted out of the strike. Curran also alleged the union planned to call out those TFs by name as “scabs.”

HGSU-UAW Vice President Evan R. Lemire said the union only used noisemakers outside of the Yard and planned the picket before learning there was an exam that day, though the union knew a large course would be taking place. He also pushed back against Curran’s letter in a statement.

“Threatening workers with discipline for participating in a strike is unlawful,” Lemire wrote. “The union had no plans for chants targeting teaching fellows.”

Get The Crimson in your inbox.

In a letter two days later, Curran claimed the union violated campus use rules during a rally at University Hall by blocking entrances and exits, banging on its doors, and posting flyers on the building and the John Harvard statue. He also alleged that the union blocked an entrance and exit at the corner of two Harvard Law School buildings during a Nov. 4 picket. Curran wrote that the University was reviewing each incident.

A Nov. 5 bargaining session between HGSU-UAW and the University also ended acrimoniously after one member of the University bargaining team walked out of the room during a discussion about third-party arbitration, bringing the session to an abrupt close. HGSU-UAW spokesperson Bonnie Jin said it was the first time University representatives had left a session early in this round of contract negotiations.

It is unclear what precisely prompted the negotiator’s exit. According to two people present, the University negotiator left the room near the end of the session after the UAW representative accused members of the University bargaining team of “enabling rape and suicide” by not allowing for an independent process to adjudicate harassment and discrimination complaints.

But Lemire and HGSU-UAW President Denish K. Jaswal, who were both present, disputed the account, saying the UAW representative only suggested that the lack of an independent process could threaten union members’ mental health and potentially lead to self-harm.

“I don’t think we ever discussed enabling rape. That I think is patently false,” Jaswal said.

Advertisement

Lemire said the back-and-forth resembled previous conversations the union has had with University negotiators about third-party arbitration. He said the UAW representative “apologized for the emotional fallout that was created by the topic” after the University negotiator walked out.

“This was not directed at a specific member of the University bargaining team,” Lemire said. “It was never said that they were specifically complicit. That’s a leap that they seem to have made themselves, which they are free to do. But it’s not what we said.”

University spokesperson Jason A. Newton declined to comment.

Deputy Provost Jessica Soban and Curran appeared to address the incident in a Nov. 6 letter to faculty, writing that University negotiators were “the target of inappropriate, disrespectful remarks” and calling the comments “not only inconsiderate, but unproductive.”

The University also proposed bringing in a mediator — a neutral third party to meet with both sides — during the session, but the union shot the offer down, Soban and Curran wrote in the Nov. 6 letter. Curran pushed for mediation again in a Nov. 10 letter to HGSU-UAW’s leadership, writing that the process had been used successfully to negotiate the last two contracts.

Jaswal said in a Monday interview that the union had not rejected the mediation offer.

“We didn’t say no to mediation. We are still considering mediation,” Jaswal said. “I think mediation is an option, but I think that, you know, we could end the strike tomorrow — at tomorrow’s session — if Harvard makes movement on some worker issues.” (Newton declined to comment, referring to Curran’s Nov. 10 letter.)

Advertisement

The unions mobilized ahead of the bargaining sessions, hosting a Monday rally with more than 200 attendees at the Zimmer Hall Plaza and urging students to contact administrators, deans, and Harvard Corporation members in support of the unions.

“I want to make it absolutely clear that every single day I’m out here is a managerial failure,” Laura Chen, a member of HGSU-UAW’s executive board, said at the Monday rally. “It is a failure of Harvard.”

—Staff writer José Luis Ortega Castro can be reached at [email protected].

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter

Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially


See more on: Labor, University

More in News


Most Read

Most Read Articles

1
  1. 2
  2. 3
  3. 4
  4. 5
Advertisement