The Culture of Hazing Isn’t Confined to the Frat House
Fraternities call it tradition. Prosecutors call it crime. Everyone else seems to look the other way.
This past month brought a litany of new hazing investigations against U.S. fraternities. At the North Carolina State University chapter of Sigma Nu, search warrants detail how multiple people complained about members forcing pledges to vomit into each other’s mouths, consume cigarettes, and drink expired milk. At the Ohio State University chapter of Sigma Alpha Epsilon, a video depicts two individuals who were allegedly doused in gasoline and set on fire.
According to reports, it was the fraternities’ pledges — college students who are accepted into a fraternity but have not been fully initiated yet — that were the subject of these dangerous rituals, often a requirement to prove one’s loyalty and become a “brother.” But I ask: What kind of loyalty lets you watch your friend burn? What kind of “brotherhood” allows its members to humiliate themselves, to make themselves sick, or even to die?
Such extreme hazing incidents are not just one-off scandals or isolated failures of otherwise normal college socialization. Rather, they set an example for young people early on that complicity equals loyalty, and belonging is only achieved by staying silent. As college students graduate and ascend structures of power, they protect each other, avoiding accountability. Thus, intense hazing lays the groundwork for a dangerous lifelong norm: that success depends on our commitment to “buy in” to an institution, no matter the cost.
The allegations brought against the fraternities at NCSU and OSU garnered extensive media attention in the last few weeks. Police have opened investigations at both schools, and the fraternities themselves have been suspended.
But brutality and punishment are not the only things that unite these cases; so does the silence of the other members involved in them. In the OSU fire video, numerous students can be seen, yet Columbus police say they received no calls about the incident on the day it took place. They only received a call after the video had already been circulating online. At NCSU, investigators are attempting to piece together what happened through seized items from the frat house, including multiple cell phones. When reporters knocked on the frat house door, no one answered.
The silence is not simply a side effect of hazing — it is essential to the process being “successful.” Hazing makes everyone complicit, no matter what your role is. You could be a pledge, member, or bystander, and you are a participant regardless. Speaking up would mean indicting your friends or yourself. Plus, the longer you stay, the more you have to lose by talking — you could be outcast and lose your sense of belonging. Thus the cycle continues, and the group redefines loyalty: A good brother is not the one who protects you from harm, but rather the one who keeps the secret.
That lesson does not restrict itself to the frat house. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh was accused by three women of sexual misconduct, and former U.S. President George H.W. Bush has admitted to touching women’s rear ends during photo opportunities. Both were members of Yale’s Delta Kappa Epsilon.
Other groups of social power similarly learn the “frat mindset,” operating off a culture of community in which every member has leverage against the other, enforcing complicity out of fear of retaliation.
Consider convicted sex offender Jeffrey E. Epstein, whose actions were allegedly covered up for years by powerful agencies, prosecutors, and politicians. Leslie H. Wexner, a billionaire retail magnate included on a 2019 list of Epstein’s “co-conspirators” created by the FBI, was a member of OSU’s Sigma Alpha Mu.
In all of these examples, the hazing logic holds true: The snitch is the traitor, and the guilty party shirks responsibility. Many of the people running these institutions learned this rule at a young age, in places like fraternities where staying quiet was the price of admission and social acceptance.
I understand that these deplorable hazing incidents do not represent all of Greek life. I am also not arguing that there is a direct pipeline between hazing and corruption. Yet the culture surrounding these practices is evocative of how those in power protect their own.
Hazing and institutional impunity both function by following the same “golden rule”: that silence is the deepest form of loyalty. Extreme cases like those at NCSU and OSU are important because they expose the insidious reasoning behind these practices, and every time we shrug off this level of hazing as “tradition,” it is only being reinforced.
Hazing laws may have increased over the past few years. Yet what happens when the logic of hazing seeps into our culture after college? At some point in the future, we will be lawyers, business leaders, and politicians, sitting in rooms where silence is the easy choice.
Will we be the ones willing to say the quiet part out loud?
Tara G. Malhotra ’29, a Crimson Editorial editor, is a joint concentrator in English and Anthropology in Cabot House.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially