Advertisement

The IOP Made Its Election Results Public. It Accidentally Made Every Ballot Public, Too.

A Crimson investigation uncovered a vulnerability in an IOP election results dashboard by tracing its data requests to a publicly accessible database and decoding all 572 ballots — leaving nearly 28 percent of voters’ choices potentially identifiable.

By Jen L. Phan and Mirei S. Saneyoshi, Crimson Staff Writers
The Harvard Institute of Politics inadvertently exposed the complete ballots of all 572 students who voted in its leadership elections this week, leaving more than a quarter of voters' choices potentially identifiable, a Crimson analysis found.
The Harvard Institute of Politics inadvertently exposed the complete ballots of all 572 students who voted in its leadership elections this week, leaving more than a quarter of voters' choices potentially identifiable, a Crimson analysis found. | By Mae T. Weir

The Harvard Institute of Politics inadvertently exposed the complete ballots of all 572 students who voted in its leadership elections this week, leaving more than a quarter of voters’ choices potentially identifiable, a Crimson analysis found.

The Crimson uncovered the privacy lapse by analyzing the source code of a results dashboard released publicly by the IOP early Monday morning. Reporters then examined the dashboard’s network calls and data requests, tracing them back to a database hosted on Google Cloud Firestore and set to be publicly accessible.

The ballots were stored in the dataset as encoded strings. But the dashboard’s code contained the instructions needed to decode them, making it possible to reconstruct each voter’s complete rankings across all races, along with their class year and program memberships.

The Crimson decoded those records, finding that 158 voters — nearly 28 percent of the ballots cast — had unique combinations of programs and class year. Names and Harvard ID numbers had been removed, but those details could allow someone familiar with an individual student’s affiliations to identify their ballot.

The Crimson did not attempt to identify any individual voter, and this article reports on aggregate figures only.

Jordan Schwartz ’27, a member of the IOP election commission, called the public accessibility of the data a “technical error.”

“The json backdoor should not have been publicly available, and the site no longer contains publicly available data,” Schwartz wrote in a statement. “We have no reason to believe that the json was widely distributed.”

The dashboard was taken down late Monday night, roughly an hour after The Crimson reached out to the election commission for comment. Program-specific voter rolls were also removed from the IOP voter roll spreadsheet.

The exposed records offer an unusually detailed look at how Scarlett E. Eldaief ’28 and Henry D. Pahlow ’28 won the IOP’s presidency and vice presidency, revealing the voting blocs that propelled them to victory.

Eldaief and Pahlow drew support from across the organization, particularly among underclassmen and members of smaller programs. Their main rivals — Tucker Coombs ’28 and Alfredo Hernandez ’28 — drew more than half of their first-choice votes from members of just two programs.

Get The Crimson in your inbox.

When the third-place ticket — Rhea P. Maniar ’28 and Justin D. Dunning ’28 — was eliminated, nearly 75 percent of the votes that transferred went to Eldaief, a Crimson Editorial editor, and Pahlow.

Here’s how the votes were cast.

Underclassmen Voters and Program Support

The race was largely decided by freshman and sophomore voters, who made up nearly 70 percent of the electorate. Underclassmen cast 183 first-choice votes for Eldaief and Pahlow, compared to 132 for runners-up Coombs and Hernandez.

Freshmen cast 203 ballots, accounting for roughly 36 percent of voters with recorded class years, while sophomores contributed 192 ballots, or about 34 percent. Juniors cast 131 ballots, or 23 percent, and seniors made up the remaining eight percent with 44 ballots. Two ballots did not have a class year recorded.

Advertisement

Eldaief and Pahlow led the first round of voting by 64 votes, with nearly 80 percent of their lead over Coombs and Hernandez coming from freshmen and sophomores. Freshmen favored Eldaief over Coombs 100 to 68, while sophomores extended that lead, backing her ticket 83 to 64. Upperclassmen were more evenly split, favoring Eldaief and Pahlow 72 to 59.

Eldaief and Pahlow’s lead was also built on breadth. Eldaief and Pahlow won the most first-choice votes in 11 of the IOP’s 17 programs and tied in a 12th, the Program for Environmental Politics. Their support originated particularly from the IOP’s smaller programs. Of the eight programs with fewer than 40 voters, Eldaief and Pahlow led in five. Coombs and Hernandez led in two.

In the first round of voting, Eldaief and Pahlow won 21 of the Harvard Public Opinion Project’s 30 votes, 20 of 30 from Politics of Race and Ethnicity, 16 of 26 from Conferences, and 16 of 27 from the Harvard Votes Challenge. Eldaief chaired PRE in 2025 before becoming the IOP’s director of operations and special projects this year.

Freshmen and sophomores accounted for nearly 70 percent of voters in the Harvard Institute of Politics' leadership elections. Scarlett E. Eldaief '28 and Henry D. Pahlow '28 won the most first-choice votes in 11 of the IOP's 17 programs.
Freshmen and sophomores accounted for nearly 70 percent of voters in the Harvard Institute of Politics' leadership elections. Scarlett E. Eldaief '28 and Henry D. Pahlow '28 won the most first-choice votes in 11 of the IOP's 17 programs. | By Zadoc I.N. Gee

The ticket also ran up large margins in bigger programs. Eldaief and Pahlow took 71 of 114 first-choice votes in the Campaigns and Advocacy Program, which Pahlow currently chairs. They also garnered 54 of 76 votes from the Policy Program and 42 of the Harvard Political Review’s 63 votes.

Coombs and Hernandez saw the strongest show of support from the programs they lead. Coombs co-chairs the John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum, where their ticket won 54 of 57 first-choice votes. Hernandez chairs the search committee for the Fellows and Study Groups program, where their ticket won 68 votes compared to Eldaief and Pahlow’s 54.

Coombs and Hernandez also won the most first-choice votes in the Global Affairs Program, Research and Strategy Group, and Governance Lab.

Advertisement

Because IOP members can belong to multiple programs, the program-level vote totals overlap.

Decided in the Runoff

No candidate secured a majority of first-choice votes in the races for president and vice president, treasurer, or communications director.

Under ranked-choice voting, the last-place candidate is eliminated after each round, and their votes are redistributed to voters’ next-ranked choices. In the presidential and communications director races, those transfers proved decisive.

Maniar and Dunning were eliminated from the presidential race after the first round. Of their 117 ballots, 73 transferred to Eldaief and Pahlow and 26 to Coombs and Hernandez. Eighteen voters who ranked Maniar and Dunning first did not rank a second option.

The transfers stretched Eldaief and Pahlow’s lead from 64 votes to 111. The ticket won the final round with 60.2 percent of the remaining ballots — securing 328 votes to Coombs and Hernandez’s 217.

Maniar and Dunning’s strongest support came from CIVICS, which Maniar chairs. The ticket secured 41 of the program’s 109 first-choice votes, accounting for about a third of its overall support. When the ticket was eliminated, 26 CIVICS votes transferred to Eldaief and Pahlow.

Advertisement

In the communications director race, Taylor P. Beljon-Regen ’29 and Aidan T. Zagel ’29 tied in the first round, each receiving 150 votes, or roughly 28 percent. Kyle S. Davis ’28 followed with 128 votes, while Oleh Shtunder ’29 and Reyaz A. Sultani ’28 won 51 and 49 votes, respectively.

After Sultani and Shtunder were eliminated, their votes split roughly evenly among the three remaining candidates — with 31 transferring to Davis, 29 to Zagel, and 28 to Beljon-Regen, a Crimson Editorial editor.

When Davis was eliminated in the third round, 78 of his ballots transferred to Zagel and 64 to Beljon-Regen, securing the race for Zagel with 51.5 percent of the remaining vote.

In the treasurer race, Layla E. Kelly ’28 maintained a safe lead in every round: she secured 245 first-choice votes, while Carter W. Umphress ’28 and Mark G. McDonald ’28 received 162 and 117, respectively.

After McDonald was eliminated, his voters split nearly evenly. Fifty-seven votes transferred to Kelly and 53 to Umphress, bringing Kelly’s lead over Umphress to 87 votes. The remaining seven ballots cast for McDonald did not rank either candidate.

Factions Down the Ballot

The split in support for president and vice president candidates also shaped voters’ first choices further down the ballot.

Advertisement

Zagel and Beljon-Regen both drew sizable support from Eldaief and Pahlow’s voter base. Of the ticket’s 255 first-choice voters, 82 ranked Zagel first for communications director and 79 backed Beljon-Regen. Coombs and Hernandez voters, meanwhile, largely favored Davis, who was the first choice of 69 of their supporters.

Some programs voted overwhelmingly for particular candidates. In the Forum, 89.5 percent of voters ranked Davis first for communications director, mirroring the program’s near-unanimous support for Coombs and Hernandez. In the Global Affairs Program, Coombs, Shtunder, and McDonald each led their respective races.

Zagel, a board member of the Harvard Political Review, won 68.9 percent of first-choice votes among HPR voters who ranked a candidate for communications director.

In the treasurer race, Kelly was the top choice of both Eldaief and Coombs supporters, winning 116 and 94 first-choice votes from each group, respectively.

Umphress saw the most support from voters who backed Maniar and Dunning best, winning 48 of its 117 voters. He also led among members of the Class of 2028, which both candidates belong to, while Kelly won 64.7 percent of first-years.

—Staff writer Jen L. Phan can be reached at [email protected] and Signal at jenphan.74. Follow her on X at @jenllphan.

—Staff writer Mirei S. Saneyoshi can be reached at [email protected] and Signal at mireisaneyoshi.09. Follow her on X at @mireisaneyoshi.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter

Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially


See more on: IOP

More in News


Most Read

Most Read Articles

1
  1. 2
  2. 3
  3. 4
  4. 5
Advertisement