Former DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson Says ICE, CBP Have ‘Lost Their Way’ at IOP Forum
Former U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh “Jay” C. Johnson criticized the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement tactics Tuesday night, arguing that aggressive policies have eroded public trust in law enforcement and weakened long-term border security.
Speaking at an Institute of Politics forum Tuesday night with Harvard Kennedy School lecturer Juliette N. Kayyem ’91, Johnson said current enforcement practices reflect a breakdown in discipline within immigration agencies.
Referring to widely circulated videos of recent enforcement actions, Johnson said the conduct of federal agents no longer resembles the agencies he once led.
“When I look at the videos of the killing of Alex Pretti, I see a force, ICE, CBP, that I don’t recognize,” he said.
“I see an angry, ill-trained, undisciplined force that looks like they’ve come for a fight and that they have lost their way,” he added.
Johnson — who led the DHS from 2013 to 2017 — emphasized that restraint and de-escalation are foundational principles of effective policing, arguing that current immigration enforcement ignores those standards.
“The consistent thread through policing in a big city are tactics in de-escalation,” he said.
“Law enforcement, whether you’re state, local or federal, have to learn tactics in de-escalation. That is so fundamental to keep carrying it out,” he added.
He cited the death of Renée Good — who was fatally shot by an ICE agent last month — as an example of what he described as a preventable tragedy.
“Renée Good did not have to die. Renée Good died because she was blocking her vehicle, supposedly preventing a removal,” he said. “I know lots of good cops that would know how to de-escalate that situation.”
Get The Crimson in your inbox.
Johnson said the recent use of force and aggressive conduct by federal immigration agents has reshaped public perceptions of ICE and CBP, rendering the agencies “toxic” in many communities. He recalled that during his tenure, people regularly thanked him for his work when they recognized his affiliation with the DHS — a reaction he said would be unthinkable today.
“Ten years ago, when I was in office, I could carry my DHS gym bag on the slot with me, and people would come up to me and say ‘thank you for keeping us safe,’” he said. “Now I wouldn’t dare wear anything that says DHS on it.”
He recounted an incident in which his teenage daughter was chased out of a party for wearing one of his Border Patrol hats.
“One night, my daughter, who was a teenager then, had the bright idea she wanted to wear my Border Patrol hat at a party in Washington, D.C., because she liked the color scheme,” he recalled. “She literally got chased out of the party.”
Johnson also criticized the Trump administration’s decision to deploy large numbers of Homeland Security personnel to cities such as Minneapolis, where thousands of DHS agents have been stationed.
“It feels to me like Minneapolis occupied territory,” Johnson said, adding that “there’s been no recent great surge of migrants into Minneapolis.”
He argued those agents would be better deployed at the border.
“All those border patrol agents in Minneapolis should be on the border,” he said.
Johnson said the current approach to domestic immigration enforcement undermines public safety in two ways. First, he argued that concentrating enforcement resources in one location weakens immigration enforcement elsewhere.
“One, by diverting into one place, one community, all these enforcement personnel,” Johnson said. “They’re not doing their job elsewhere.”
Second, he said aggressive tactics have damaged relationships between federal agencies and local governments.
“When ICE becomes toxic in a community, the locals don’t want to work with them anymore — the mayors, the City Council all pass ordinances and laws saying ‘we will not work with ICE,’” Johnson said.
Turning to broader structural issues, Johnson argued that the Department of Homeland Security itself is in need of reform, saying its post-9/11 structure no longer reflects present-day threats.
“That model is now outdated,” Johnson said, explaining that DHS was created to address counterterrorism as an external threat. “Terrorism now can be foreign inspired or home run.”
When asked by Kayyem how ICE should be reformed, Johnson emphasized narrower priorities.
“Leadership and new priorities focused on the criminals,” he said.
—Staff writer Jen L. Phan can be reached at [email protected]. Follow her on X at @jenllphan.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially