City Council Narrowly Votes to Keep One-Way Traffic on Garden Street
The Cambridge City Council narrowly voted to maintain one-way traffic on Garden Street, walking back a proposal to implement two-way traffic and bidirectional bicycle lanes after weeks of mounting pressure.
The policy order was adopted in a 5-4 vote after more than 100 residents weighed in on both sides over months of City Council meetings. On Monday, councilors directed the city to abandon the redesign slated to begin this summer, leaving the street’s current one-way configuration in place.
The debate over traffic on Garden Street, which runs alongside the Radcliffe Quadrangle, has remained in limbo for several years. A 2022 City Council vote first established one-way traffic, reducing travel lanes as part of a broader effort to reconfigure the corridor. The City Council reversed the change in 2025, voting to restore two-way traffic and add bicycle lanes.
Monday’s decision marks yet another reversal, halting construction just months before it was scheduled to begin.
The vote came after Councilor Timothy R. Flaherty exercised his charter right two weeks earlier, delaying the decision by a week. The move, he said, was intended to give councilors more time to weigh the implications of reversing a previously adopted policy order — a consequential choice that should not be taken lightly, he argued.
The City Council has recently revisited several policy decisions made over the past few years, including considering amendments to the multifamily zoning ordinance that could reverse changes passed last February. Those debates have raised concerns among residents and councilors alike, many of whom argue that quickly reversing policy decisions undermines the city’s decision-making process.
Resident Andrew Zhou, one of 92 people who spoke during public comment on Monday, voiced support for keeping Garden Street one-way. He said the 2022 decision reflected a carefully developed community consensus, adding that its reversal in 2025 was a “partisan insult” to the city’s public engagement efforts.
Get The Crimson in your inbox.
“The move back to a two-way Garden Street is not just fiscally irresponsible, not just recklessly unsafe. Moving back to a two-way Garden Street is a partisan insult to our civic process,” he said. “It is an indignity.”
In the weeks after invoking his charter right, Flaherty said he canvassed residents on Garden Street, going door to door to better understand their views.
“I knocked on I don’t know how many doors — I think the number is 258 people spoke to me. Maybe 75 percent preferred the two-way traffic,” he said. Flaherty ultimately voted in favor of the two-way proposal.
Mayor Sumbul Siddiqui, framing the debate as one marked by competing but valid perspectives, urged both councilors and residents to approach the issue with mutual respect, even as tensions remained high.
More than 40 residents spoke Monday in favor of keeping one-way traffic on Garden Street, while fewer than 10 supported the two-way proposal.
“I want to acknowledge the frustration that people have felt in the room and probably those watching from home and what they’re feeling. I share the frustration,” Siddiqui said.
Councilor Jivan G. Sobrinho-Wheeler, who supported the one-way plan, pointed to years of public debate over traffic flow on Garden Street as a reason to maintain the current design. He argued that another overhaul would impose unnecessary costs and disruptions on both residents and city staff.
“Folks have adapted and gotten used to the new pattern of Garden Street,” he said. “It doesn’t mean it’s happy for every single person, but ripping it up, spending another quarter of a million dollars, forcing people to deal with more construction, putting more city staff on the streets isn’t going to solve the issues here.”
—Staff writer Risha Sinha can be reached at [email protected].
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially