The Winding Road to Public Service
Say you’re a 20-year-old college student who values public service. You’re a member of Harvard’s Institute of Politics, and you spent your summer registering voters. Upon graduation, though, you end up optimizing business operations from a desk in a New York City high-rise. Is this first career choice a deviation from your moral values, or could it serve as a safety net for your future?
Time and time again, we question why a substantial proportion of our senior class enters finance or consulting careers directly after graduation. Harvard students seem to neglect public service.
Spending their precious undergraduate years running polls, hosting speaker events, or tutoring children, “IOP kids” wouldn’t come to mind as the most likely participants in recruiting events. But the tide has turned: 58 percent of the IOP’s Executive Team members from 2016 to 2020 started their careers in public service compared to 19 percent since then. But students interested in politics may want to set themselves up for what will almost certainly be an unstable career by joining the private sector for a short period post-grad.
Is this just a continuation of a larger trend at Harvard? Of all graduates entering the workforce in the Class of 2026, 19 percent went into finance, and 17 percent went into consulting — the two largest categories, while just 4 percent went into public service and nonprofits.
There may be another explanation. Politics is a notoriously risky, unpredictable field, where your job may well disappear based on the opinions of Americans every two to four years. Even worse, on the campaign trail, jobs are changing by the day. When a student has to consider job stability, choosing a stable private-sector career before transitioning to politics may not mean tossing personal values out the window. Rather, they may just be making a rational choice for their long-term career goals.
If I were to take a job at a congressional office, I would need to fight for a selective spot as a staffer, find housing in Washington, D.C. on a salary possibly half that of what my fellow Harvard graduates were making, and accept the fact that my boss may be booted to the curb by constituents in just two years. The cycle would repeat, or I’d join a super PAC.
Politicians often face criticism for their lack of experience in a “real” job prior to entering professional politics. In an interview with The Crimson, one former IOP member turned strategy consultant noted, “Politics is a little bit of a bubble.”
Just look at former U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg ’04: After his tenure as IOP Student Advisory Board president, he worked at McKinsey & Company before becoming an intelligence officer in the Navy Reserve. Buttigieg stood to gain practical business experience, understand the private sector, and earn an income after receiving a master’s degree from Oxford University. Buttigieg’s time in consulting does not make him any less of a public servant, and it may have offered him valuable insights into real-world economic decision-making.
Harvard’s pre-professional culture may breed a certain kind of selfishness, one that prioritizes self-enrichment over societal contributions. This argument ignores the positive externality that a stable first job can provide. Up to roughly 30 percent of junior consultants leave their companies after two years, with skills and extra cash in their pocket for their next venture. Students going into politics should be afforded the same stable career setup.
The IOP was founded in 1966 to inspire young people towards working for the public good. Sixty years on, the inspiration is clearly still working, albeit delayed.
Taylor P. Beljon-Regen ’29, a Crimson Editorial editor, is a Government concentrator in Leverett House.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially