‘Dexter: Resurrection’ Season 2 Premiere Review: A Masterful Blend of Old and New
5 Stars
On Oct. 30, “Dexter: Resurrection” aired the premiere of its second season on Paramount+, promising an exciting new addition to the “Dexter” saga. With a new slate of serial killers for Dexter to track down and his son ironically joining the NYPD, the premiere is an excellent start to what looks to be an action-packed season.
The new season comes 20 years after “Dexter” first aired on Oct. 1, 2006. The series follows the story of Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall), a serial killer who works as a blood spatter analyst at Miami Metro Homicide. Greatly influenced by his adoptive father Harry Morgan (James Remar), Dexter follows a strict code that compels him to only kill other killers. Fans fell in love with Dexter as a relatable and comedic assassin struggling to balance his violent side hustle with his day job and relationships with his girlfriend, Rita (Julie Benz), and his sister, Deb (Jennifer Carpenter).
The original “Dexter” ran for eight seasons, but fans were notably disappointed with Season 8 and the series finale, which got a dismal 4.9 out of 10 on IMDb. In 2021, the sequel “Dexter: New Blood” set in Iron Lake, New York attempted to revise the ending. However, the “New Blood” ending was just as, if not more, divisive.
In July 2025 “Dexter: Resurrection” aired as a sequel to “Dexter: New Blood.” This time set in New York City, Dexter reconnects with his son Harrison (Jack Alcott) and takes on mysterious serial-killer-admirer and billionaire Leon Prater (Peter Dinklage). The new iteration provided exactly what fans had been waiting for, and over its 10-episode run it averaged a 9.3 on IMDb.
Season 2 offers even more Dexter adventures to look forward to. In the first episode, titled “Risky Business,” Dexter tracks down Al Walker (Eric Stonestreet), a killer from Prater’s club that he first encountered in Season 1. In addition, Harrison graduates from the police academy to become an officer of the NYPD, mirroring Deb’s role in Miami Metro Homicide in the original “Dexter” and setting up potential father-son collaboration within the NYPD in future episodes.
In addition, the episode also introduces new serial killers that could play major roles in Season 2: The New York Ripper (Brian Cox) and the Five Borough Killer (Dan Stevens).
The episode is written to set up parallel plotlines of Dexter’s hunt for Al, Harrison’s graduation, and the Five Borough Killer’s dark agenda. While the episode excels in introducing these new plot elements, what makes it truly stand out is how it perfectly blends old style with new perspectives. Dexter is the character fans have always loved, while introducing a fresh angle as he adjusts to life in New York City, navigating his relationship with Harrison and grappling with middle age.
The classic stylistic elements that made “Dexter” a phenomenon back in 2006 are thankfully still there: The iconic title sequence from the original “Dexter” makes a comeback in Season 2, and Hall’s portrayal of Dexter’s inner monologue remains core to the show. Dexter’s commentary is sometimes humorous, sometimes pensive, yet always surprisingly relatable.
Hall’s performance is remarkable because he remains faithful to the character while insightfully portraying the changing priorities that come with age. Dexter has aged 20 years since the original series, and now his role as father to Harrison is crucial to his identity. In this premiere, Dexter humorously wonders if he’s having a midlife crisis, a concern Season 2 promises to explore.
While keeping key elements from the original show to keep the classic “Dexter” tone, the episode also does an excellent job introducing style elements to fit the current moment in 2026. Notably, the soundtrack features recent pop songs in tandem with the show’s original score. For example, Harrison listens to Tame Impala’s “My Old Way,” which contextualizes his character as a 21-year-old living in 2025. Visually, the sweeping city and coastal shots of Miami featured in the original series are replaced by gorgeous NYC skyline panos.
Moreover, a cohort of new actors bring life and fresh perspective to the NYC setting. Since “Dexter: New Blood,” Hall and Alcott’s dynamic has been core to building tension as Dexter is forced to choose between his personal life and tracking down killers. Ntare Guma Mbaho Gwine returns to play Blessing Kamara, a Ur Car driver whose remarkably friendly and hospitable demeanor gives the show needed warmth. Kadia Saraf returns as Claudette Wallace, dead set on solving the case of the notorious New York Ripper. Her deadpan performance establishes Detective Wallace as a brilliant, idiosyncratic detective to be reckoned with.
Fans should be looking forward to a riveting season of “Dexter: Resurrection” ahead. The premiere sets the tone with a talented cast, gripping plot elements, and a perfect blend of classic Dexter style with the new show’s modern-day New York City setting. So go ahead, give it a watch: Tonight’s the night — for an exciting new season of “Dexter: Resurrection.”
New episodes air Fridays on Paramount+.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially