Hawksmoor Review: Go Big or Go Home
Chef Thomas Park — 3.5 Stars
After 20 years of international acclaim, Hawksmoor made its New England debut in Fort Point, Boston. The ambiance of Hawksmoor is exquisite, with the bar casting a subtle warm light onto the royal blue upholstery as the murmured chatter of a filled room swells and lulls. Its dark wooden interior, light jazz, and seafront views set the scene for a traditional steakhouse; and yet, the menu alludes to something more creative, offering British fusions like a lobster crumpet and even a special Sunday roast menu. For visitors willing to fully commit to the experience, a meal at Hawksmoor is an indulgent celebration of British steakhouse dining.
A Thursday night high-top seat, nestled between two other groups, can have a wait time of over an hour; in other words, a reservation is non-negotiable — even for a solo diner. More so, the right side of the menu is not for the faint of heart either, as the price is directly related to effort, flavor, and quality given by the kitchen. To truly enjoy Hawksmoor, it is best to save your visit for a special occasion and close your eyes when signing the check.
When that day arrives, order the charcoal-roasted scallops. They are — in every definition of the word — perfect. The scallops rest on their shells, which are secured to the plate with a smear of mashed potatoes. At first bite, the flawlessly golden breadcrumbs create a delightful foundation of texture that is quickly harmonized with the tender scallop underneath. The acidity of lemon adds a much-needed brightness to balance the rich and buttery shellfish.
image id=1389338 align=center size=large caption=true
The garlic butter, white port, and citrus pool together into a thin sauce, composing an intricate and expertly balanced flavor profile that one might consider drinking. This is, sadly, proven difficult as the liquid finds itself into the grooves of the shells quite easily. That being said, with three scallops per starter, it’s worthwhile to consider ordering more than one for the table. This dish, truly, is a masterclass in scallop preparation.
Unfortunately, the same is not to be said of the steak frites, a cheaper “bar-bite,” ringing in at a reasonable $35. While most Hawksmoor steaks come sideless, albeit accompanied by charcoal-roasted bone marrow, this rendition boasts beef fat fries and a steakhouse salad. However, don’t be fooled, these beef fat fries are not the same as the $10 side offered on the menu. Both are named “beef fat fries,” but one is stick-thin and unremarkable, while the side order fries are noticeably thicker and have been awarded second-best fries at their sister restaurant in Chicago by Chicago Mag. If unclear, the former is provided here alongside a sickeningly sweet accompaniment of homemade Hawksmoor ketchup for dipping. Still, the fries weren’t the biggest disappointment, nevertheless offering a good crunch despite inconsistency in salting.
The steak had similar seasoning problems, with some bites being almost inedible as a result. Even more disappointingly, the dish arrived lukewarm and quickly cooled, which was evident as the meat became harder to chew. While this is in part due to the cheaper cut, as the sear seemed decent, there is also some fault to the preparation as a whole. There were pockets of fat in the steak that did provide an enjoyable reprieve from the flavor and added softness to the texture, though some bits did teeter on chewy. There is an option to opt for a $10 upgrade to a Châtel Farms Akaushi Wagyu, which according to the waitstaff only added more fatiness to the dish.
image id=1389336 align=center size=large caption=true
Considering that most restaurants regard steak frites as a bare-bones, monotone classic, the inclusion of a salad was appreciated. However, “salad” is a big word for the greenery left behind on the plate. A few pieces of meek, lifeless greens and paper-thin shavings of radishes weren’t even doused with olive oil, let alone a vinaigrette. While the greens were close to being bitter, the radishes did add a pepperiness to the otherwise salty — rather than flavorful or even benign — flavor. It would be advised to simply split a pricier steak and avoid the hassle of justifying this entree.
None of this discredits the restaurant as a whole; the scallops alone make it worth a visit. Hawksmoor clearly has the potential to expand its initiatives in affordability, but there is no doubt that investments in more lavish dishes are the focus of the cooking staff. Hence, this restaurant is to be enjoyed with no mind to matters of time and money: Order a cocktail, you’ll probably stay a while.
—Staff Writer Maia M. Abed can be reached at [email protected].
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially