Federal Judge Temporarily Blocks Restriction on Student Work Authorizations
U.S. District Court Judge Julia E. Kobick ’05 ruled on Tuesday to temporarily block the Trump administration from upholding updated guidance limiting international students’ ability to work internships while studying in the U.S.
The preliminary injunction blocks the enforcement of two Student and Exchange Visitor Program broadcasts issued in August, instructing universities to only authorize Curricular Practical Training — a form of visa authorization that allows students on F-1 visas to participate in work experience related to their field of study — if the experience was a graduation requirement.
According to the federal messages, violating this policy carries administrative and legal consequences for universities and their employees — including potential revocation of SEVP certification, which enables universities to host international students.
In October, a coalition of four higher education groups filed suit against the DHS over the broadcast messages, alleging they were “procedurally invalid” and went against nearly four decades of precedent in the interpretation of CPT rules.
Harvard is linked to all four plaintiffs in the suit: the Association of American Universities, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, and the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts. The University is a member of AAU, the Presidents’ Alliance, and AICUM, and NAFSA’s membership includes Harvard International Office staff.
The dispute over the messages rests on how to interpret the word “integral.” While CPT authorizations have required work experience to be “integral” since 1991, that had not historically been interpreted as necessary for graduation — until the August 24 message explicitly defined it.
In a 24-page memorandum accompanying the injunction, Kobick focused on the alleged procedural issues with the messages — writing that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the argument that the federal government had acted without reason or fair basis in releasing the messages because they marked a shift from customary interpretation of CPT rules without explanation.
“Correct or not, this new interpretation is inconsistent with the government’s previous position—what it now calls plaintiffs’ ‘more liberal regulatory reading’— on CPT for elective training taken for academic credit,” Kobick wrote in her memo.
Kobick wrote that she decided to issue an injunction and stay of agency action because she believed the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in the case and because they had demonstrated their members would “suffer irreparable harm” if the messages remained in effect.
Get The Crimson in your inbox.
Universities across the country paused CPT authorizations after the messages were issued — including Harvard, which does not currently offer CPT at five of its schools: Harvard College, Harvard Medical School, Harvard Law School, the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, and the Graduate School of Design.
“Institutions have already had to expend substantial resources to comply with the Broadcast Messages,” Kobick wrote in Tuesday’s memorandum.
“The broadcasts also threaten institutions with the loss of SEVP certification for noncompliance and DSOs with criminal liability for making false statements,” she added, referencing Harvard’s ongoing suit against the DHS over its efforts to revoke the University’s SEVP status in May 2025, which established loss of certification could be considered “irreparable injury.”
At least one school — University of California, Berkeley — has resumed processing CPT requests following Tuesday’s injunction. Harvard has not updated its CPT guidance in the days since the ruling. A spokesperson for Harvard did not respond to a request for comment.
A spokesperson for Immigrations and Customs Enforcement declined to respond to a request for comment, citing a practice of not commenting on pending litigation. The Department of Homeland Security — ICE’s parent department — called the lawsuit “performative outrage” in a statement to The Crimson in October.
“Where was the outrage when foreign nationals were abusing the system, violating the terms of their student visas, and making a mockery of our immigration laws?” a DHS spokesperson wrote.
Tuesday’s ruling comes on the heels of another decision limiting the federal government’s push to tighten rules around student visas. On Monday, a federal judge rejected a planned rule that would have limited student visas to four years and introduced limitations on international students’ ability to change academic trajectory.
Over the past two years, the federal government has intensified efforts to restrict student visas — efforts which have sometimes been aimed directly at Harvard. The Trump administration revoked Harvard’s SEVP certification in a May 2025 letter — though both the letter and subsequent notice of intent were blocked by injunction after Harvard sued the same month.
An appeals court has yet to rule on the government’s request to overturn the injunction blocking the proclamation. The government indicated it would not enforce the initial letter in an August court filing, and at an October hearing, a Justice Department lawyer suggested the Trump administration would likely reissue the decision if their appeal is unsuccessful.
—Staff writer Sebastian B. Connolly can be reached at [email protected] or on Signal at sbc.23. Follow him on X @SebastianC4784.
—Staff writer Summer E. Rose can be reached at [email protected] or on Signal at ser.85. Follow her on X @summerellenrose.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially