Advertisement
News

At Kennedy School Forum, Former Iranian Hostages Say Regime Must Go — But Democracy May Not Follow


Former Iranian hostage Siamak Namazi spoke at a virtual Harvard Kennedy School forum on Iran's escalating crisis and the uncertain prospects for democratic change.
Former Iranian hostage Siamak Namazi spoke at a virtual Harvard Kennedy School forum on Iran's escalating crisis and the uncertain prospects for democratic change. | By Ryan N. Gajarawala
By Sophia E. Alcacer, Crimson Staff Writer

Former Iranian hostage and businessman Siamak Namazi warned Thursday at a forum at the Harvard Kennedy School that while Iran’s ruling regime may be approaching collapse, democracy is unlikely to follow.

The panel, co-sponsored by the Institute of Politics and the Carr-Ryan Center for Human Rights Policy, brought together former political prisoners and human rights advocates to examine Iran’s escalating crisis amid a nationwide crackdown on protests and rising tensions with the United States.

The discussion, originally scheduled to be held at HKS, moved online due to the weekend snowstorm and was moderated by international human rights lawyer Jared Genser, who spent nearly a decade advocating for Namazi’s release.

Genser opened by detailing the recent surge in state violence, citing mass detentions, executions, and Iran’s deteriorating economy. In early January, reports emerged of as many as 30,000 deaths amid intensified protests. Iranian authorities quickly shut down internet access, triggering international condemnation and prompting threats of a military strike from the Trump administration.

Namazi placed part of the blame for the bloodshed on the United States, arguing that President Donald Trump repeatedly encouraged Iranians to protest while promising American support that never materialized.

“The President of the United States urged the Iranian people to stay out in the street, promising the cavalry is on the way. He said that eight times, by my count, and many listened,” he said. “They went out on the street and they got slaughtered. The cavalry never came.”

Hadi Ghaemi, the director of the Center for Human Rights in Iran, described the regime’s response as a calculated atrocity.

“This was a very premeditated, systematic, international massacre that shook the country and the rage. I don’t think we quite understand it,” he said.

Namazi added that regardless of whether the U.S. launches a military strike or reaches a diplomatic agreement with Tehran, neither outcome would undo what Iranians had already faced.

“Whether there’ll be a military strike or whether the U.S. will ultimately strike a deal, neither of those moves will undo the carnage that took place,” he said. “It won’t stop the regime’s violence against its own people, the violence that we said we wouldn’t allow.”

Get The Crimson in your inbox.

Morad Tahbaz, an Iranian environmentalist and Namazi’s former cellmate, said he was frustrated that world governments have failed to hold Tehran accountable.

“It’s painful to know that what you’ve been through, the interrogations, the torture, the separation from your families, everything, and we finally get out, and after a while, it’s almost like nothing has happened,” Tahbaz said. “No one’s come up with a way of punishing the regime.”

Tahbaz also pointed to fractures within the opposition as a major obstacle to regime change, saying that protesters have struggled to unify around a shared vision for the country’s future.

“It’s a big problem, in the case we have in Iran right now, people are not coming together,” Tahbaz said.

Neda Bolourchi, the director of the Public Affairs Alliance of Iranian Americans, offered a blunt assessment of what regime change would require, saying she did not see a new state forming without “additional, stronger, coercive violence.”

Advertisement

Still, some panelists saw openings. Ghaemi argued that the Iranian regime is weakening, even as its coercive apparatus remains intact.

“The regime is now almost looked at as a foreign presence. Historically, it’s our responsibility to uproot it,” he said. “It still has all means of coercion. It still has the revenue of oil money, and the people do not have much support.”

But he said a new solidarity between Iranians inside the country and the diaspora abroad could prove decisive — and urged mid- and high-ranking military commanders to defect.

“There is a historical responsibility on our shoulders, on all our shoulders right now, inside and outside of the country,” Ghaemi said.

“This regime is collapsing, meaning that people within the regime realize that it is over. And, if they are given an opportunity to join something new, they will,” he added. “Coalition is the ultimate answer.”

—Staff writer Sophia E. Alcacer can be reached at [email protected] and Signal at sophiaalcacer.88. Follow her on X at @sophiaalcacer.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter

Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially


More in News


Most Read

Most Read Articles

1
  1. 2
  2. 3
  3. 4
  4. 5
Advertisement