Experts Say ‘Clock is Ticking’ for DOJ After Admissions Suit Dismissal
Legal experts said that a federal judge’s procedural dismissal of the Trump administration’s lawsuit for Harvard’s applicant-level admissions data could give the University room to stall, potentially long enough for shifting politics to weaken the government’s case.
U.S. District Court Judge Myoung J. Joun dismissed the Department of Justice’s lawsuit earlier this month, claiming the federal government had failed to meet sufficient procedural requirements to merit judicial intervention. But Joun did not rule on the merits of the case, leaving room for the government to refile — and a government spokesperson told Inside Higher Ed that the DOJ plans to.
Still, the government cannot appeal the decision directly, and must instead refile under correct proceedings — a lengthier process that some experts said could help Harvard delay litigation until President Donald Trump’s term ends in 2028.
University of New Mexico law professor Vinay Harplani said the decision hands Harvard the opportunity to delay action in a potential refiling until the next presidential election.
“I think the strategy here that Harvard’s employing — or that I would employ if I was Harvard — is just kind of delay it,” he said.
“We’re going to have another election in two years, where the Trump administration or the Republicans could be out of office and have a Democratic administration. They may not pursue all of these investigations, they may well end all of these investigations,” Harplani added. “So what this does is just pushes everything down the road.”
Stetson University law professor Peter F. Lake ’81 similarly said that the ruling “kicked the can down the road.”
“I’m sure that there are people supporting Harvard who are thinking, perhaps it’s just a game of sitting things out now for two more years,” he said.
The recent midterm elections — which shifted control of Congress to the Democrats — could also have an impact on the federal government’s approach.
Northwestern University law professor Paul A. Gowder said a Democratic Congress would be less likely to pursue future legal action against universities.
Get The Crimson in your inbox.
“We’re not likely to see that continue when Congress has switched parties. So that’s going to sort of take away from the kind of depth of the ability of Republicans who want to harm universities to actually be able to do so.” Gowder said.
But Daniel Curell, a lawyer and former senior adviser to the Department of Education, wrote in an email that he expected the looming elections would prompt the DOJ to continue pressing for Harvard admissions data.
“Their clock has 2 years left in it for this administration, so there’s no reason for them to stop pushing,” Curell wrote. “I would think that this is a pretty big priority for them, so I wouldn’t expect it to stop.”
Lake said that, for this case and other legal battles faced by the University, the Trump administration may be running out of time to get this case to the First Circuit or Supreme Court.
“At this point, the clock is ticking,” he said.
The DOJ’s February suit follows years of scrutiny into Harvard’s admissions practices. In 2023, the Supreme Court’s landmark Harvard v. Students for Fair Admissions ruling barred the consideration of race or ethnicity in higher education admissions.
The lawsuit — which followed a subsequent Justice Department review into the University’s admissions practices — aimed to give the DOJ access to information it claimed would help it determine whether Harvard was in compliance with the 2023 ruling.
Some experts said Joun’s ruling could be seen as a warning to the federal government — despite the lack of commentary on the merits of the case itself.
“I think it’s also kind of a yellow flag to the government to say we’re going to be skeptical if what this looks like is a fishing expedition to try to make Harvard’s life harder,” Georgetown University professor Frederick M. Lawrence said.
“I would see this as actually kind of a sympathetic decision towards Harvard,” Harplani said.
Spokespeople for Harvard and the DOJ did not respond to requests for comment.
—Staff writer Alexa M. Schmitt can be reached at [email protected] or Signal at alexaschmitt.15. Follow her on X @alexa_m15_s.
—Staff writer Celine Muir can be reached at [email protected] or Signal at celinem.33. Follow her on X @celinemuir1.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially