When Workers Strike, Harvard Needs a Lesson Plan
A strike is inherently disruptive. But Harvard ought not make the confusion worse.
Last Tuesday, Harvard’s non-tenure-track faculty and researchers went on strike after a final bargaining session the day prior ended without a contract agreement. Their union — Harvard Academic Workers-United Auto Workers — represents roughly 2,600 preceptors, lecturers, teaching assistants, and postdoctoral researchers across the University. Though HAW-UAW voted to end the strike yesterday, the damage to academics is done.
For a week, undergraduates got a crash course in just how much of their education depends on those workers. Students taking Expository Writing, the College’s foundational writing course, received centrally assigned busywork in place of the individualized instruction that characterizes the class. Some seniors lost thesis advisors in the middle of course registration. Other classes stopped meeting altogether.
As the strike severely disrupted the University’s core academic mission, the administration failed to fulfill its educational responsibilities.
Every reasonable effort should have been made to support continued instruction and distribute clear information. Ideally, Harvard would have swiftly communicated concrete guidance to students and instructors on how class sessions and grading would proceed, tailored by course type and department. Instead, students received information helter-skelter on course policies during the strike.
Even with grade inflation, we’d struggle to give the administration an A-minus.
Where possible, tenured and tenure-track professors could have filled in. Small courses such as introductory math could temporarily become larger lectures to stretch faculty time. None of this replaces the invaluable work of researchers and faculty, but it’s certainly better than leaving students to fend for themselves.
Last year, we supported HAW’s efforts and urged Harvard to eliminate time caps on non-tenure-track appointments. The strike has made clear how much students stand to lose when the people they rely on are suddenly gone.
As any student who’s sat through a dull section could tell you, our staff is equally full of excellent and terrible teachers. Harvard should make it easier to retain those who excel, and give them more opportunities to teach. Teaching quality should also be made a more important consideration when awarding tenure or rehiring teaching staff.
Teaching fellows, another core part of the undergraduate learning experience, should likewise receive more rigorous training. We applaud recent efforts in the right direction, such as the Faculty of Arts and Sciences’ new requirement for non-faculty teaching staff to further train at the Derek Bok Center for Teaching and Learning. The graduate students hired to do this difficult job should be limited, and the few hired should be compensated strongly for their efforts.
Anyone who’s tried getting into a beloved Gen Ed knows that Harvard students take good teaching seriously. Tenure and hiring committees should pay as much attention to the Q Guide as we do.
Harvard has spent the past year promising to recenter academics. The University had a chance to prove this isn’t just a slogan — and it failed the test.
This staff editorial solely represents the majority view of The Crimson Editorial Board. It is the product of discussions at regular Editorial Board meetings. In order to ensure the impartiality of our journalism, Crimson editors who choose to opine and vote at these meetings are not involved in the reporting of articles on similar topics.
Have a suggestion, question, or concern for The Crimson Editorial Board? Click here.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially