Even though a long-awaited discussion on a school-wide honor code will take precedence on the agenda of this month’s Faculty meeting of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, professors said they still expect to find time to discuss secret email searches uncovered in early March.
Tuesday’s meeting will be the first since revelations that Harvard administrators authorized the covert search of 16 resident deans’ email accounts last fall, opening what many have called a breach of trust between the faculty and administrators. The searches have prompted many to call for greater transparency and an assurance from the administration that faculty privacy is protected.
But the meeting is also the first chance faculty will have to discuss the implications of the Government 1310 cheating scandal and broader questions of academic integrity at Harvard, a dialogue absent from recent faculty meetings.
Mathematics professor Wilfried Schmid said he hopes that email searches are addressed but is glad to see the discussion shaped by academic integrity.
“I think that on balance, whether the process works well, I would say that if we look at these three items—the emails, the cheating scandal, and the SEAS issue—they have not been handled correctly,” Schmid said, the latter referencing the announcement that the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences would move to Allston.
History professor Maya R. Jasanoff ’96, who sits on the Faculty Council and chairs the Faculty Docket Committee, said the meeting’s agenda was crafted to give faculty a chance to talk about the broader issues of trust and communication raised by the email searches, while still allowing for several concrete proposals to move forward. These include a Committee on Academic Integrity report and a proposal for changes to reading and exam period, both presented by Dean of Undergraduate Education Jay M. Harris.
While many professors said they were surprised the searches were not included in the meeting’s docket, most said they are confident that the issue will be addressed explicitly during question time and implicitly in the docketed agenda items.
Jasanoff said that she and the Docket Committee expect both Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences Michael D. Smith and University President Drew G. Faust to make statements about the searches.
“The email searches themselves as a fact, they happened, and we expect to hear certain responses from administrators about them, but in and of themselves they are not so much something that needs to be discussed,” Jasanoff said. “The bigger questions about trust, ...those are things that really need to be discussed and need to be discussed in the many, many forms in which they manifest themselves.”
—Staff writer Nicholas P. Fandos can be reached firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow him on Twitter @npfandos.
In Wake of Email Scandal, Professors Mourn Loss of TrustFour days after news broke that Harvard administrators secretly searched the email accounts of 16 resident deans last September, professors called on administrators to address what one called a corroding of a “culture of trust” between the faculty and its leaders.
Step Up, President FaustI’ve been giving President Drew G. Faust the benefit of the doubt through the many Harvard scandals over the past year, but her handling of the Resident Dean email search debacle is where I draw the line.
Revelation of Second Email Search Contradicts Administrators' Previous Statement
To Rebuild Trust, Hammonds Must ResignSince Hammonds provided misinformation regarding the highly sensitive issue of email searches, and since she violated clear policy regarding those searches, her presence at the helm of the College stands as a roadblock to rebuilding trust between students, faculty, and the administration. For the good of the University, Hammonds must resign.
Email Search Fallout Prompts Dismay Over Privacy, TrustIn response to revelations of a previously undisclosed round of secret email searches announced at a faculty meeting Tuesday, student representatives expressed concern about administrative transparency surrounding email privacy, including the security of the students’ own accounts.
Admitting Email Search Errors, Harvard Turns to Boston LawyerUniversity President Drew G. Faust acknowledged in an interview Tuesday that administrators do not yet have a complete picture of the sequence of events surrounding secret searches of resident deans’ email accounts, but said she hopes a forthcoming review by esteemed Boston attorney Michael B. Keating will clarify lingering uncertainty.