EEOC Doubles Down on Faculty Hiring Subpoena, Opposes Harvard’s Discovery Request
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission urged a federal judge Monday to force Harvard to turn over years of hiring records, arguing the University had not met the high bar for dismissing the case or for digging into the agency’s internal deliberations.
The EEOC’s lawsuit, filed in September, asks the court to enforce a June subpoena for granular hiring information tied to an April 2025 charge that the University violated civil rights law by discriminating against white, Asian, straight, and male applicants.
The sweeping subpoena requests a laundry list of documents related to Harvard’s faculty hiring practices dating back to 2018, including its Faculty Hiring Guide, all applicant materials submitted for faculty positions, demographic data for those applicants, and a slew of records about diversity-related activity at the University.
Harvard asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit in a Nov. 6 filing, arguing the EEOC brought the case to retaliate against Harvard for suing the Trump administration over its federal funding freeze in spring 2025. The EEOC, for its part, has said that seeking enforcement of a subpoena was standard procedure after Harvard was uncooperative during negotiations and turned over a “partial” list of documents.
If the court declined to dismiss the case, Harvard asked for limited discovery and an evidence hearing to review exchanges between the EEOC and other governmental officials or outside parties, communication with the press, and documentation related to a decision to assign the investigation to the Houston instead of Boston office. The EEOC opposed those requests in two filings Monday.
The University argued those records would bolster its claims that the commission acted improperly by retaliating against Harvard for its standoff with the Trump administration, leaking its charge to the press, and moving the investigation to its Houston office.
Harvard suggested in its filing that the government made an “illegal disclosure” of the charge by leaking it to the Washington Free Beacon, a conservative publication that obtained the documents shortly after it was filed.
“Harvard never released nor consented to the release of the Charge, and because Acting Chair Lucas filed the Charge, there is no nongovernmental party to the Charge who could have made it public,” Harvard wrote in its Nov. 6 filing. The EEOC called the allegation “a baseless accusation with no supporting evidence” in its response.
Get The Crimson in your inbox.
Harvard also called the subpoena too vague and practically impossible — or at the very least unreasonably burdensome — to comply with. The University’s lawyers estimated it would take “thousands of hours” and $1.2 million in Faculty of Arts and Sciences faculty time to track down records on the roughly 1,389 faculty searches and almost 41,000 faculty applications since 2018.
Harvard cast the subpoena as an attempt to shape the University’s faculty composition — a long-held goal of the Trump administration.
The EEOC pushed back on both claims in its Monday response. It argued that its actions over the course of the investigation were not out of the ordinary, and that even if its charge was in part related to the Trump administration’s campaign against Harvard, a “mixed-motive action” could proceed as long as it rested on some underlying merit.
Lawyers for the EEOC also wrote Harvard would need to show “extraordinary circumstances” to obtain discovery — a bar they argued it did not meet — and that discovery would significantly intrude on internal agency deliberations. They also accused Harvard of using the discovery request to drag out the litigation, estimating it would take up to six months to satisfy.
“For all of Harvard’s speculation, its papers are devoid of any allegations of misconduct by anyone in the Houston District Office – or anyone at the EEOC, for that matter – in deciding to issue the subpoena,” lawyers for the EEOC wrote. “Harvard’s objections – though sprawling – are, at bottom, about simply not wanting to turn over specific information.”
The EEOC added that letting Harvard off the hook to keep the government out of faculty hiring would carve out a misguided exception for academic institutions from Title VII enforcement.
“Respondent cannot evade the subpoena by asserting that an investigation into whether it has complied with Title VII with respect to its employment practices threatens its First Amendment rights,” lawyers for the EEOC wrote.
—Staff writer Hugo C. Chiasson can be reached at [email protected] or on Signal at hcc.35. Follow him on X @HugoChiassonn.
—Staff writer Elise A. Spenner can be reached at [email protected] or on Signal at elisespenner.82. Follow her on X @EliseSpenner.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter
Have a tip for The Crimson? Share it confidentially